General Question

Zissou's avatar

Do you use both commas when a modifier follows a coordinating conjunction?

Asked by Zissou (3374points) March 31st, 2018

Grammarians, which do you prefer, (1) or (2):

(1) [clause],[coordinating conjunction][modifier],[clause].

(2) [clause],[coordinating conjunction],[modifier],[clause].

Examples:

(a) The door was unlocked, but(,) knowing what was on the other side, I did not open it. [participial phrase]

(b) It’s going to rain, so(,) unless you want wet seats, you should roll up your car windows. [subordinate clause]

(c) Joe has worked very hard, and(,) like many people, I was happy for him when he won the competition. [adverbial phrase]

(d) Kim apologized, and(,) surprisingly, Pat forgave her. [adverb modifying a clause]

I have observed variation when constructions like these immediately follow coordinating conjunctions. Which do you prefer, and why?

Please note that (2) should not be confused with incorrectly placing a comma after a conjunction:

(e) *He ate it. But, he didn’t like it.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

5 Answers

ragingloli's avatar

Depends on whether or not I want to emphasise.

elbanditoroso's avatar

Two commas. For clarity.

Jeruba's avatar

Yes, if you’re treating it as parenthetical. You could make a case that all four of those instances are parenthetical.

I would consider the added commas necessary only in (c) and (d). (I’d also add “other” before “people” in  (c).)

And I would certainly delete that comma in (e).

I don’t, by the way, generally see grammar as a matter of preference. There’s room for plenty of variation, and there is style, which sets a choice among acceptable alternatives; but preference does not outrank correctness in cases such as (e).

If these constructions appeared in a document that I was editing, I would make sure to follow one rule consistently throughout.

Zaku's avatar

I think that often the first comma feels overly-deliberate and is not needed, though as @ragingloli mentioned, it can be included for emphasis.

In general I leave out the first comma, as in my previous sentence.

Zissou's avatar

Thanks for your responses. I tend to favor punctuation that is based on the grammatical structure, rather than some of the other considerations that get mixed into it, and I agree that parentheticality is the key issue here. I’m not sure that a subordinate clause is parenthetical in the same way as the others, though. I find myself dropping that first comma in cases like (b).

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther