My thoughts on that are the same as my thoughts on any other relationship: do your best to be respectful to everyone involved. If you sleep with a man who lives platonically with a roommate, it’s no disrespect to the roommate. If you have noisy sex with him and keep the roommate awake, that’s another matter. If your man is in any kind of sexually exclusive relationship, even if it’s just a FWB, then his partner(s) have a good-faith expectation of being kept…abreast of his activities.
They have good-faith expectations on you too, whether they know you personally or not, for you (and everyone else) to honor their agreements, not be a participant in dishonoring them. And that’s any kind of agreement, not just an agreement to sexual exclusivity. His employer has a good-faith expectation on you not to help your man embezzle money from the company.
I have more thoughts. We don’t choose whom we love. Or whom we lust after. One could make some glib comment about how despite those facts, we can still control ourselves, we can still resist temptation. But the only people who say that are people who haven’t ever been tempted beyond their limit. No, no one ever held a gun to my head to make me cheat on my girlfriend in high school. I was tempted beyond my limit, meaning, I was tempted enough to disrespect my girlfriend. Other people would have resisted that much, only to fall later. Others later still. Only the strongest people can resist the strongest temptations. You’re no more beholden to the standards of someone morally stronger than you, any more than that person is beholden to the standards of someone much stronger
M, if you’re out there, I’m really sorry. With any luck you forgot me long ago.
If I were to pass some judgment, I would be unfairly trying to hold you accountable to my capacity to resist temptation. That would be the same as judging you for not being able to lift as much weight as I can at the gym. I’m not bragging or anything, but I can bench at least 25 pounds. I can’t judge anyone for not being as brawny as I am.
You have my sympathy. I just recently did something incredibly disrespectful to a close friend. I was tempted enough to treat him that way. Let me serve as an example for you: I withheld knowledge from my friend that he had a good-faith expectation of having. When he found out, I lost a friend. A good friend. If you are tempted beyond your limit, and you decide to have sex with this man, tell your partner if you have one, and tell your man’s wife. Tell them. I have felt like shit for quite a while, not just because I lost my friend, but also the pain of losing him forced me to think, and I thought about how he must have felt, reviewing our history as friends in light of the vital information I had always kept from him.
Even if you don’t mind disrespecting them now, even if you don’t care about them, take care of yourself. It’s agonizing to think of how much it hurts them, and unless you’re made of steel, you will think about it.
T, if you’re out there, I’m really sorry. With any luck you’ll forget me.