We don’t have a tradition that we make sure we do every year, but we often give each other cards on our anniversary. Sometimes made from scratch, but always some really nice handwritten words to go along with whatever is printed if anything is printed. I do keep cards my husband has given me in a shoebox. I looked up one year anniversary, and the traditional gift is paper, maybe that could be the paper?! A box for you both to put keepsakes in? Cards, theatre tickets, printed photo, whatever you want that you would want to see 20 years from now. I know everything can be electronic now, but one box of things in print, similar to a time capsule, can be really fun and meaningful to go through. My shoe box has cards and post cards, and letters from my husband, sister, parents, etc. I love it.
Another thing my husband has done some years that I really like is he looks up the traditional or modern gifts, and sometimes does something funny with it. Like our 15th anniversary he went out of his way on a snowy day to buy me Krystal burgers. It was one of my favorites, because we weren’t going to buy gifts, but then someone he works with was flabbergasted he wasn’t going to buy me anything, so they came up with this funny thing to do since 15 years is Crystal on the traditional list. It only works because I truly don’t care if he buys me nothing on our anniversary, some women have high expectations and would get bent out of shape. I thought it was hilarious and thoughtful.
I just googled and 1st year is paper for traditional or a clock for modern. I read that young people can’t even read analog clocks anymore, I don’t know if that true, and I don’t know how old you are, but there are some beautiful clocks out there. I usually still with the traditional list though, if I bother with anything.
We go out to dinner usually also, but we go out to dinner anyway once or twice a week, so that to me isn’t a big deal.
I say be creative. I also like @YARNLADY’s festival. That sounds really nice. You might not find something like that the first year your married though. Traditions sometimes start when you don’t expect it.
Are you trying to surprise her? Or, are you two going to discuss it? Some people are freaks about having to receive a gift and it has to be a good enough gift, blah blah, or a more expensive restaurant than your usual, etc. I think It’s good to know the other person’s expectation, so they aren’t let down.