Another split :(
And then the American Revolution came, and it presented everyone with a strange situation. To the gentlemanly British, the Revolution was a mess in every aspect possible: the American Army consisted of a lot of officers who were traders or farmers with slightly higher intelligence and respect than their subordinates, which was a strange thing considering everything I mentioned earlier. The Americans were fighting against the country that was supposed to be part of their place, and as a result they weren’t supposed to be considered real soldiers, but instead criminals. And their motivation for fighting was to become an independent country, which was far different than the motivation of previous wars, which was for gentlemen to show each other who was boss. As a result, the British was very reluctant to treat the American soldiers the same way they treated their previous enemies.
But the Americans saw nothing strange in their war. To them, they were legitimate soldiers, fighting a legitimate war, and should be treated with respect. As a result, the American officers expected to be treated the same way as the European officers. This led to a dispute for some time before the British finally gave in and treated officer prisoners with the same standards I mentioned earlier. Ethan Allen was an example of that. He was put in jail with the common soldiers before the British gave in and gave him a parole. One reason for why the British gave in was because Washington threatened them to treat their British prisoners the same way if they didn’t respect the Americans, in direct response to Ethan Allen’s arrest. And of course the British couldn’t have that with their gentlemen.
And this led to a lot of conflict between the common people most particularly Loyalists and the soldiers. To the Loyalists, the Patriots were nothing more than pesky criminals, yet they were given a house, fed well and were able to move around like nothing had happened. To them, this was a big insult to justice. Some people got so angry that they took the matter into their hand and assaulted the Patriot prisoners. It didn’t help either that some Patriots even put on their uniforms and walked around to tease the Loyalists.
And because the Patriot officers didn’t always belong to the upper class, some of them didn’t hold too strongly to the “honor” concept of the Europeans. This led to some prisoners escaping their imprisonment when the opportunity arose. And some Patriots even encouraged this by coming to the places where the prisoners were held and performed “rescue missions”. Those people were of the minority though. Washington didn’t like that either, even blatantly telling everyone that any officer escaping would be put back to imprisonment if caught.
This is actually the basic of my story. My Continental Army character is a prisoner and the girl he meets is the host of his house. The town they are in has a large number of Loyalists, and they flat out hate the officer.
Side note: at the start of the Revolutionary War, the Americans actually strove hard for an “egalitarian” war: it didn’t matter which class you belonged to, as long as you wanted freedom and could fight, you were welcomed to join. But over time, war leaders were slowly forced to adopt the standard European class system to their army. The reasons for this change were:
– People, especially lower class citizens, simply ran out of steam. At the start of the war they were enthusiastic. But then they slowly realized that the war lasted longer than they thought, and they just couldn’t afford to dedicate their life to the war when they had other more important things to attend to like their families. It started to take more and more to motivate them to join the war other than just the goodness of their heart.
– The war leaders started to realize that there was the reason why the European system existed in the first place. Think about it: in a middle of a heated battle on a vast open field, with your enemies firing and charging at you, and anyone can die at any moment, it’s extremely crucial that your soldiers are disciplined enough to stay in their position and not overcome by fear and run away. The only way to make sure that happens is to train them to fear the leaders and obey orders without question. And to do that, you need a strong-willed leader who is not only good at keeping everyone in line, but also good at keeping himself in line. And that all leads back to… the European class system.
– The small American militias had proven to be ineffective against the British army. The militias’ biggest weakness was their lack of discipline and direction. They were more like “there’s the redcoats! Fire at them! Die lobster die!”, while the British soldiers had clear plans, and strong-willed leaders guiding everyone into the battle. The militias might win initially, but over time the British’s persistence and strategic thinking would overpower them all. This was the reason why the Continental Army was created, to bring the soldiers together to form an organized force against the British.