Guitar buying advice?
Hi y’all
As some of you know I’m a bluegrass banjo player. I’m not very good, but I enjoy it and I’m in a band. I have a Martin D-18 clone guitar that I picked up used at a bluegrass festival but the action is kind of high and it’s a dreadnought style which has that wide body. I play it from time to time when needed.
My wife, out of the blue, told me she’d like to take guitar lessons. My Martin is a little hard to play if you don’t have a pick so I’d like something smaller with lighter action that she can strum and learn chords. (I am not going to teach her—I have a guitar teacher in mind). I’m thinking of something like a ¾ Yamaha. Guitar Center sells one for about a hundred bucks or so, but I don’t know how good it is. I can spend more if I need to. I just want something that is easy to learn and play.
Any ideas?
Observing members:
0
Composing members:
0
11 Answers
I’m learning to play on this guitar, which was recommended to me specifically as a beginner guitar by a friend who plays and teaches professionally. The thinline body makes it easier to hold and get your arm around than a dreadnought, and you still get to practice with something that is otherwise standard size. I really like it so far, but I’ve only had it for a few months.
If you have the time, reach out to a more specialized guitar shop and ask if they offer guitar services. There are shops that will tune up a guitar specifically for a beginner (replace or file-down inappropriate bridge, lower action, file down problematic frets, etc). These people can work magic on an inexpensive beginner guitar. They might also have some suggestions. There are also smaller-scale guitars that work well for beginners with smaller hands (Martin LX1E, or less-expensive ¾-scale models).
Get her a regular acoustic guitar to learn on.
My brother has been playing guitar for many years, and was in a few bands over those years. He plays bass, 6-string,12-string, mandolin. He played French horn back in his early school days. And he has a banjo.
But here’s the thing: He can’t get the hang of that 5th string on a banjo. Your wife may have trouble with it, too. So I suggest a regular guitar to learn on.
(My brother tunes the banjo like a regular guitar and no one knows the difference.)
Response moderated (Spam)
I have an acoustic cedar top Seagull with a great, warm sound. They’re not cheap, but not crazy expensive either. In my opinion, the ¾ size might be a mistake, but a slimmer body could make sense.
@kritiper I have two regular guitars—one is a Martin dreadnought and the other is a travel guitar. Problem is they don’t fit her right. She’s not planning on playing the banjo. I’m the banjo player.
@gorillapaws Thanks. I’m not married to the ¾ size. Full size would be fine. I’m more interested in the smaller body that is easier to wrap around.
@JeSuisRickSpringfield That’s a good option, thanks
@product Thanks. I have lots of friends who are musicians, and I was planning on asking for their help as well. I also have a friend who is a luthier (he is building me a banjo). But I wanted to get some outside help from fluther as well.
@gorillapaws Can you link me to something like what you have?
Here’s a link to their S6 Original Slim. That might be a good choice. That said, I wouldn’t buy anything on the internet without her holding the thing first to make sure it works with her frame.
They make small guitars for kids. Or she could learn to play bass on a ukulele…
@kritiper I have two ukuleles. She’s more interested in a guitar. I spoke with the guitar teacher and he’s going to loan her a parlor guitar to try out.
Answer this question
This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.