I’m a Christian.
I adore Narnia and the Lord of the Rings. I pretty much love anything by C.S. Lewis, including his much deeper stuff.
So maybe this will sound strange, but if a book is written solely for the purpose of being Christian fiction, I think it would turn me off. But on the other hand, if I’m reading a good fiction book, and the main character, or one of the main characters, happens to be Christian, then that wouldn’t bother me and I would probably enjoy that fact.
Although I see no relationship between typical romance novels, mysteries, and Christian fiction, I feel much the same about all of them. I don’t read romance novels, even those that aren’t on the rack for $1.99. If I’m reading a good book, and it happens to have romance in it, then I have no problem with that and often enjoy it, but I don’t want to read a book that is solely about a romantic relationship. By the way, I feel like there is more romance between Aragorn and Arwen than in most other books
Same thing with mysteries. I don’t automatically want to read a book because it is a mystery. If the background theme, if you will, is interesting and then there happens to be a murder that is solved, that’s fine. But there’s got to be a lot more about the book that draws me in. There are a couple of Agatha Christie books that I love, but that by no means inducates I’m interested in reading a bunch of her books. One good example I can think of are the rabbi days of the week mysteries. Sorry I can’t remember the author, but it’s something to the tune of the rabbi went to lunch on Monday, etc, etc. I like those mysteries because I learn a lot about the Jewish faith and that fascinates me. There’s another author that centers his mysteries around horse racing, and because I never truly forgot my love of horses and horse racing from when I was young and read The Black stallion books, I enjoy those.
So basically, I want to learn something when I read, and not just read something because it’s a bunch of fluff.