If I were moving to the city now, I’d live in Northern Liberties, or just North of Girard. It’s a pioneering area at the moment (N of Girard, I mean—N Liberties is already The Place) but there’s land to be had and shells of houses to be remodelled, and you’re just North of Northern Liberties, and there are lots of pubs and coffeehouses and galleries, and even clubs. It works whether you’re a musician, a young family, or single. I drive past it every day, and my mouth waters, but I’m settled in West Philly.
You can get small yards just about anywhere in the city. If you want a big yard, then you have to go to Mt Airy, which can be pricey, and is a longer commute to center city. You could also try Germantown, which has many graceful old houses that are being reclaimed from neglect. If you’re anarchists, you should live in West Philly, near the A Space. Wobblies also live in the neighborhood, and they have a book store there. If you don’t know what a Wobbly is, you should find out, because it is a venerable part of US history.
Schools: well, if you live in Powelton village, Chestnut Hill, or Queen Village, you can send your daughter to public school (Powell, Henry, and Meredeth schools, respectively). There may be a few other elementary schools that are good in other neighborhoods, but I’m not familiar with them. Oh, there’s the new university sponsored school in West Philly. If you want to go to any of these schools, make sure you get a house inside the catchment area. We live 50 feet outside the catchment area for the university school, and thus have to send our kids to progressive school (read private school).
Private school is a tradition in Philly because of the Quakers. I think we have perhaps the highest portion of children in private school of any major city, and this was also true before racial problems. I.e., it isn’t white flight. Of course, if you go to private school, you can expect to pay at least 24K a year. Parochial schools are a good deal less expensive. Public schools are free, of course. So you can see the advantage of living in a neighborhood inside the right area. That would also preclude Northern Liberties, I think.
Philly is a big city that feels like a small town. You run into people you know all over the place. Because of the Quaker influence, there is this notion that we are all “Friends.” Concensus building is an important thing here. You may not notice these things at first, but eventually, you’ll start to notice it.
I ended up here by accident, and have come to love it very much. I came in a recession, and have seen the city grow carefully. We’re not as badly off as others who indulged in wild growth. There’s so much culture here, and a lot of very interesting things going on that don’t necessarily get publicized outside the city. It’s a gem, and at the very least you should visit, even if you don’t live here.