Social Question

SQUEEKY2's avatar

In your opinion will the Republican complaining of the open southern border stop after the mid terms?

Asked by SQUEEKY2 (23468points) October 25th, 2022

Just wondering will they turn real quiet about the border after the election?
Because here in Canada we only hear about how bad that border is, is during elections.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

13 Answers

Entropy's avatar

If you’ve only been hearing about it during election season, then I think your news source is the reason. Conservatives are very agitated about the topic and there is a large logistical problem that is falling on their states and towns. And they’ve been complaining about it pretty constantly for the last couple decades.

Remember the 2000 election when Al Gore was complaining that Pat Buchanan’s position on the butterfly ballot caused people to mistakenly vote Buchanan instead of Gore? Buchanan was running on an anti-immigration platform and his movement was the precursor to what Trump co-opted when he jumped into the fray.

So this definitely isn’t a new thing.

Demosthenes's avatar

Well, open border rhetoric and talk of caravans and “invasions” are spoken of more before elections, certainly. It’s not a new issue but rhetoric is ramped up when it’s politically advantageous to do so. According to these narratives, the border was apparently “closed” during Trump’s tenure and is now open, though that is not true and the numbers don’t bear it out either (border crossings were down during the pandemic for obvious reasons, but were high during the first couple years of Trump’s presidency, so it’s not as if it’s only Biden and the Democrats that oversee a problem with illegal crossings). It’s an ongoing issue that neither side has been able to adequately address.

Zaku's avatar

They complain more around elections, but my impression is most who complain about that don’t seem to ever stop complaining about it.

Smashley's avatar

No. It’s a big unresolved issue that matters to a lot of people. Republicans will keep banging that drum into power but only to maintain power. They would never intentionally reform the system. Privatize perhaps. Militarize, definitely, but not reform.

kritiper's avatar

No. Besides, it’s just as much the Republican’s fault as it is the Democrats, if anyone is to blame.

KNOWITALL's avatar

No. What @entropy said.

seawulf575's avatar

I think it depends on what you are asking. Are the Republicans on the street going to continue complaining about border? No. They will continue to push on this regardless of who wins the majority in Congress. Will the politicians running for office stop pushing it as a topic? Some will, some won’t and some of that will depend on who wins. For several decades now people have been complaining about the illegal immigrants pouring across the southern US border. And politicians have used this as a vote-getting thing. Dems and Repubs have all “promised” to do something about immigration and as soon as they are voted into office they completely ignore it until the next election.

Nomore_Tantrums's avatar

Probably. Got to distract their base voters attention from JB Fatwallet hiring all of them he can, while they look the other way.

Blackwater_Park's avatar

This is a long standing issue that will not go away until something is done about it.

Strauss's avatar

It’s interesting that those who don’t like immigrants are descendants of immigrants.

SQUEEKY2's avatar

Ya know @Strauss as much as I disagree everything political with @seawulf575 I do agree with him about illegal immigrants, do it legal and welcome.
They really shouldn’t try and circumvent the immigration process, be it American or Canadian.

seawulf575's avatar

Thanks @SQUEEKY2 I knew we had common ground somewhere ;-)

Blackwater_Park's avatar

Not wanting wide open borders has nothing to do with not liking immigrants. It has to do with the need to be more pragmatic about immigration.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther