I’m sorry Harp, but you don’t understand the purpose of our criminal justice system. What you are talking about is a reform system. American don’t want reform. They want justice, and that means punishing the bad guys. It doesn’t matter that the form of punishment makes those bad guys more likely to commit further crimes, rather than less. It doesn’t matter than punishment dehumanizes people, and makes them part of a permanent underclass. Justice must be done! The American people believe this so much, that they are willing to fund the largest prison system in the world. Never mind that this costs so much more than rehabilitation programs. Punishment must be meeted out, so justice can be served. There is no price we are unwilling to pay for justice.
And that means, at least in the US, that a person who is a pedophile due to a brain tumor will be punished. Someone has to be punished. Why not the person in the body that committed the crime?
Not so many months ago, on another social networking site, I raised a similar issue. I have personal experience with being of two different minds! I was in one mind, where I was mean to everyone, and constantly irritable, and I wanted to die. Then, I was given drugs, and soon thereafter, I was looking back at the way I had been, and while I remembered doing everything, and I remembered it making sense at the time, I could not believe I would have done that, and I could never make the choice to behave that way in my current frame of mind.
I asked who was I? The bad guy, or the current guy? Harp said “both,” which was really helpful. But here’s what weirded me out: it was a pill that made the difference. The difference between good daloon and bad daloon is a pill. What that pill did, was to literally change my thoughts. It changed the contents of my thoughts.
Well, in the not too distant future, we’re going to discover how to manipulate people’s thinking with chemicals in a much more specific manner. When we do that, then where does responsibility go? Where does personality go?
I behave in one way with one kind of chemical balance in my brain. I behave another way after that chemical balance has been adjusted. I think this is very troubling. Not just because it suggests that I’m driven by factors external to my will, but also because it opens the door for secret mental manipulation of individuals, if you can find a way to get them to ingest the proper chemicals. It is very troubling. The case of the pedophile with the brain tumor is equally troubling.