Social Question

Dutchess_III's avatar

Why did Hitler have such a problem with Jews?

Asked by Dutchess_III (47059points) April 27th, 2024

What? Why?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

24 Answers

cookieman's avatar

(retrieves 10-foot pole from closet)

LifeQuestioner's avatar

It wasn’t just the Jews, although obviously they were a major group that was persecuted and murdered by Hitler. But he persecuted many groups such as African Americans, disabled people, etc. All in the name of his master race. But I think also he used the excuse (wrongly, mind you) that the Jews had killed Jesus, which has been an ongoing point of many Christians to persecute the Jews. When, if you read the bible, the Jews are still considered the people of God and are said to have a part when Jesus comes again.

Tropical_Willie's avatar

He didn’t want any Jews in his country, he used it as a focal point to oppress a group, to get backing for takeover of the World.

seawulf575's avatar

I think there were several reasons for his focus on the Jews. First, he did not invent antisemitism. It is far older than that. He was influenced by other antisemites who came before him. But he was fanatical. His belief in the “master race” was one that he used to stoke up support. Secondly, I believe he used Jews as a test case. He wanted to see if he could focus on one group and get his followers to do whatever he wanted them to do against that “enemy”. Choosing Jews was easy since antisemitism was already known in the world. Interestingly, he studied the US Democrat’s Jim Crow laws to help him craft laws that aided in going after Jews.

JLeslie's avatar

There was plenty of antisemitism already in Europe including Germany. Partly based in religion, Christians blamed Jews for killing Christ, and also from stereotypes. Jews are always a minority in a country so they are easy to target. How much Hitler believed or just used his reasons to hate the Jews to gain favor among the people who followed him I don’t know. It was easy for many Germans to follow a leader who hated Jewish people.

Hitler blamed the Jews for being part of the reason Germany lost WW1. Hitler wanted a master race, and generally promoted the German race as superior, it was not just about blonde hair and blue eyes. Jews were thought of as an inferior race, not just a religion, but rather Jewish by blood. Germany was having economic troubles and Jews were used as a scapegoat for the economic problems.

Jews tended to be well educated in Germany and many had good positions in society so they were targets of jealousy for those who struggled. As a a side note, that wasn’t the case in Eastern Europe where Jewish people were still often targeted; in Eastern Europe the Jews were more likely to be poor and peasants.

Hitler certainly targeted other groups too as others have mentioned. Disabled people, Gypsies, other minorities, and people who helped the Jews.

I figure either Hitler truly believed ridding the planet of Jewish people was a good thing, or, he was a pure psycho masochist who enjoyed murdering people, and it was so “easy” to murder the Jewish people in huge numbers. The Nazis were methodical about it sometimes killing 30,000 people a day for days straight. I think he must have gotten a real rush from killing, like I hear about serial killers. I think it is like an addiction for them maybe.

I sent the Q to ragingloli.

seawulf575's avatar

I have heard many times that Christians hate Jews because Jews persecuted Jesus. I have never understood that, even from when I was a child. Jesus was a Jew. And as a Christian, I was always taught that Jesus was destined to be persecuted and crucified. We are taught he was the sacrificial lamb of the new covenant. I have 100% believed that the Pharisees and Sadducees of the day were horrible people based on the accounts of the New Testament, but that does not equate to Jewish People or even the Jewish religion.

I would say that any Christians that hate Jews need to take a break and pull out their bibles again.

JLeslie's avatar

@seawulf575 I think present day most Christians think like you, but maybe some extremists don’t. I really don’t know regarding the religious aspect. I don’t hear Christians who hate Jewish people talking about Jews killing Jesus, I hear them chanting things like “the Jews will not replace us” and they frame Jewish people as harming the country, that Jewish people are trying to control everything in the world, trying to remove freedom to practice Christianity, the WS is even blaming Jewish people for the border problem on our southern border. They will blame Jewish people for anything and everything.

seawulf575's avatar

@JLeslie I just don’t understand it. Let’s say there are some people trying to control everything and they are Jews too. Correct me if I’m wrong, but I can’t think of any teaching in Judaism that would drive a person to try controlling everything under dictate of God. Ignorance is astounding, sad, and horrible all at the same time.

JLeslie's avatar

@seawulf575 I don’t know what these WS people think, but I doubt they care what Judaism teaches. They talk about George Soros and point out Jewish ownership of businesses, stuff like that. They can make up anything and these extremists will believe it. Jewish people are not white to them, we are in the same boat as Latin Americans and Blacks, tainting the white race.

Caravanfan's avatar

Libraries of books have been written on this, and any pithy answer would give it short shrift, but I’ll try. He thought Jews were responsible for the rise of Communism, and he felt that the Jews were behind the resistance to Germany during the Great War. He saw Jews as responsible for the economic problems faced by Germany in the 20s.

I recommend a couple of books
The Racial State by Burleigh
and
The Holocaust: An unfinished History by Stone

flutherother's avatar

I don’t buy into the theory that Hitler hated the Jews because they crucified Christ. Was Hitler religious? I don’t think so. The crucifixion theory seems more like an attempt by the Nazis to get the German churches on their side.

Anti Semitism in Germany began to increase dramatically after the Germans lost the First World War in 1918. The Germans refused to accept they had been defeated on the battlefield and claimed they hadn’t really lost but had been “stabbed in the back” by various factions on the home front, chiefly Jews and socialists. Hitler used the resentment this caused to build his support. Everyone was to blame for the problems of Germany except Hitler and the Nazis.

Caravanfan's avatar

It has nothing to do with the crucifixion. He truly believed the Jews were subhuman

Dutchess_III's avatar

His Mom was a devout and pious catholic @flutherother

MrGrimm888's avatar

Of note.
Hitlers mother was being treated by a Jewish doctor, when she died suddenly.
Those who knew Hitler, said that the event hit him VERY hard.
He was a changed man, without his mother, whom he was very close with.
Historians point to this fact, as the likely origin of Hitler’s antisemitism.
Other Historians, claim that the fact that the doctor was Jewish didn’t matter to Hitler.
After all, they sought/accepted the help of the Jewish doctor in the first place.
It’s hard to see 1940’s Hitler, as having a Jewish doctor.

I agree with most here, that it was not just a Jewish hatred.
Although it’s important to note that Hitler rose to power after Germany had suffered defeat, and signed treaties that would financially stunt Germany for years to come.
(BMW, actually still complies with the agreement they made following WW1, in which they agreed never to construct aircraft again. That’s why the BMW emblem is a propeller. The company was an aircraft producer.)

Many German people were feeling the agony of defeat, mixed with the economic despair caused by sanctions and treaties, and were ripe for a charismatic leader to come along and blame someone for their woes.
As there was a preexisting antisemitism in Germany, and Jewish people were not affected as badly by the loss of WW1, they became an easy scapegoat.
Hitler was very bold. With every great victory, he aimed his sights higher. He was actually very lucky, that the world was still very much suffering from war fatigue. So. Other countries were slow to help one another.

Hitler betrayed Mussolini, and Stalin.
A lot of Russian people, were Jewish. As a strategy for keeping his country in war mode, it helped his cause to sell the ill-advised fall invasion of Russia to his generals, and people.

Hitler, like many people, was an opportunist.
He basically crafted his own story, with lies of his military service in WW2, and painted himself as a savior to Germany.
He also had to overcome the previous regimes, and older styled thinking German public.

I HATE, to go here, but here I go.
This is the same strategy Trump ,and those like him are using.

Writing their own narrative, and choosing a “bad guy,” they can stir fear about. All just to ride preexisting concepts, knowing that the anger was already there.

Some people, obviously will use anyone, and/or anything, to claw their way into power.

Getting people to unite on a common perceived enemy, plays into our built-in tribalism.
If there is no enemy, one can always be manufactured.
Then, groups have a “purpose.”

The better question is, why did all those German people play along in such pure evil?

No leader would ever exist, without a lot of other people keeping them in power.
That is the relationship between a country’s people, and their leaders.
The “leaders”(politicians,) are always trying to romance people into liking them. Even if there is never an authentic reason.

Hitler spoke to the darker parts of his followers’ hearts. Where petty things like hating people just for who they are is.

He taped into their pride as well.

Sheep. Sheople. That’s the weakness that Hitler took advantage of.

Caravanfan's avatar

@MrGrimm888 ” The better question is, why did all those German people play along in such pure evil?”

It wasn’t just the Germans. Antisemitism and fascism were more than just Germany. Lots of countries and lots of regular people were complicit.

Dutchess_III's avatar

It’s insane.

Demosthenes's avatar

@Caravanfan has provided the best answer so far. Antisemitism in Germany did not begin with Hitler, but it was a current he was able to seize upon after the German loss of World War I. Jews were scapegoated (as they had been countless times throughout European history) as being largely responsible for Germany’s loss and economic devastation following that loss (Jewish bankers and financiers always portrayed as benefiting from the economic depression). A significant part of Hitler’s anti-Jewish animus in Mein Kampf was rooted in his belief that The Protocols of the Elders of Zion was genuine and revealed the plot of Jews to take over the world (this was before he’d explicitly decided on the “final solution”). By 1939, though, the conspiracy he believed in was much more clear:

“If the international Jewish financiers in and outside Europe should succeed in plunging the nations once more into a world war, then the result will not be the Bolshevization of the earth, and thus the victory of Jewry, but the annihilation of the Jewish race in Europe!” -Hitler, 1939

JLeslie's avatar

I feel like it’s more than complicit for many of the Germans. They agreed with the actions and also in other countries in Europe at the time. Some went along or did nothing for fear for their own lives, it’s understandable, but disheartening.

Then there is the rest of the Nazis, and in my belief was a large percentage (I’m not saying the majority of Germans, but many) did believe in German and white superiority and agreed with the genocide. They were bought-in and thought Hitler was great. That’s what I think anyway.

The Jews and over 3 million others who were murdered had done nothing against the government or people of Germany or the other countries involved, they were killed purely out of hate, a belief those people were subhuman, and a fantasy that it would fix the problems in Germany at the time.

Probably Jewish people were seen as equal and powerful in German society in Germany leading up to Hitler they were so interwoven in society, so antisemitic complaints were ignored. I’m just guessing.

That is part of the complaint by some Jews today in the US. I am talking going back even before Oct 7th. I’m aware of a woman who was having a problem at work years ago, and she was told she was not a minority because she’s white, and since she wasn’t religious and it wasn’t a complaint about not getting a holiday off anyway, she didn’t get any protection for feeling she was being treated unfairly. I don’t remember what her exact complaint was. My point is as antisemitism ramps up, if it continues too, some interpretations of the laws will not help the Jewish people, because they are seen as part of the majority and white in the US and many complaints are not related to religious freedom or specifically related to the practice of the religion.

Smashley's avatar

Because he was an asshole.

Caravanfan's avatar

No @Smashley, to characterize it as such misses the point. Antisemitism was rampant in Europe, as it was in Britain and the US. But Europe was worse because of the Great War, and the Nazis capitalized on European sentiment. It wasn’t just Hitler and the Nazis. It was a huge chunk of the population. The Nazis just took advantage of it.

JLeslie's avatar

What @Caravanfan is emphasizing is a worthy point.

This has some statistics for Jews killed in Europe during the Holocaust listed by country: https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/jewish-losses-during-the-holocaust-by-country

I read recently that 90% of Jewish children were killed, I don’t know how accurate that was, but you can be sure it was a very high percentage.

Before the Holocaust there were Pogroms in Europe, here is an article: https://www.timesofisrael.com/20-years-before-the-holocaust-pogroms-killed-100000-jews-then-were-forgotten/

In the Middle East some leaders aligned with the Nazis and killed or pushed out Mizrahi Jews (Eastern Jews). Here is an article about that. https://www.timesofisrael.com/ignored-by-the-un-mizrahi-jews-survived-pogroms-and-expulsions-too/

My husband’s paternal side of the family are Mizrahi Jews, you will see them referred to as Yemeni Jews and also some say Arab Jews. My FIL speaks Arabic and Hebrew. My husband’s grandparents left the ME in the 1930’s partly because of rising antisemitism, and my FIL was born in Mexico. Some of his older siblings were born in Tel Aviv and Haifa. Here is an article about that: https://www.timesofisrael.com/ignored-by-the-un-mizrahi-jews-survived-pogroms-and-expulsions-too/

Every Jewish person has some sort of connection to these various massacres. Either family who died; or escaping just in time; or friends with parents or grandparents who had numbers on their arm; or from countries that did not give them citizenship; or from the area of the Pale, where Jews were allowed to live, but could not go beyond the Pale. The list goes on and on. Here is some information about the Pale f you are interested: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pale_of_Settlement#:~:text=The%20Pale%20of%20Settlement%20included,now%20the%20western%20Russian%20Federation.

MrGrimm888's avatar

@Caravanfan Yes. Fascism.
That was REALLY what was the disease.
ANTIFA, a group some right-wing people believe Obama created, actually originated in “Mussolini’s” 1930’s Italy.

The stories I have always heard, is that it wasn’t just Hitler.
He had an entire nation, wrapped around his finger.
Citizens were encouraged to be part of the genocide, and war.

From the streets of quaint old European villages, to the death camps, an army of people weren’t just complicit, they mostly all participated.

That, to me, is the worst factor.

That’s why I won’t just sit here, if Trump starts deporting millions of people. We know the outcome, of such behavior.

Smashley's avatar

https://youtube.com/shorts/n0fvtI_B9o4?si=ba7I3gEYl_1OlsaN

And anyone who thinks he wasn’t an asshole should probably do a bit of research. He started a whole war a while back.

Caravanfan's avatar

I didn’t say he wasn’t an asshole. I said that it’s far more complicated than that.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther