General Question

Dutchess_III's avatar

Do you suppose church congregations vote the way their pastor exhorts them to?

Asked by Dutchess_III (47126points) 1 month ago

And do you think preaching politics is out of line?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

22 Answers

ragingloli's avatar

I bet they do.
And if they do, they need to lose tax exemption.

jca2's avatar

I am guessing that many do. The pastor can be very influential and he or she has a captive audience.

I am guessing that many do not.

Look at the millions of people that follow the pope and whatever he says about popular topics like contraceptives, abortion, etc.

JLeslie's avatar

Yes. The majority yes.

Blackwater_Park's avatar

Birds of a feather flock together. It’s more the other way around. A pastor has to pander to the congregation or the pews are empty and by extension, the collection plate. Some people blindly follow but for most, religion is simply a Rorschach test. The bible certainly is. To have a congregation there need to be enough people thinking the same way and a leader to regurgitate what those people want to hear.

LifeQuestioner's avatar

My church doesn’t preach politics at all.

chyna's avatar

^Mine doesn’t either.

seawulf575's avatar

I’ve never joined a church that preached politics. And the times that the insanity of the world comes into a sermon, I certainly don’t let that be a reason to vote one way or another.

Blackwater_Park's avatar

My uncle was a universalist unitarian preacher for a while. He had a “Jesus was a liberal” sermon we all still jab him on.

SnipSnip's avatar

No, not generally. I’m sure there are political statements made when they should have been kept to self. I’ve never witnessed politics from the pulpit, but I am but a single Presbyterian.

Zaku's avatar

I’m afraid way too many do.

And, listen to rural US “Christian” radio some time, for a bombardment of bullshit about Trump being sent by God, natural disasters being due to US tolerance for gay marriage, how Democrats are evil, etc etc. It’s scary and hard for me to believe it exists, or that anyone follows it.

MrGrimm888's avatar

Duh?
That IS THE point of organized religion. To control people…

flutherother's avatar

Not directly, but politics and religion are connected by ethics and our political choices should be guided by our ethical beliefs.

Forever_Free's avatar

Church goes believe in the craziest of notions in the first place. Of course they will believe in and do what someone else says. That’s the definition of religion, isn’t it?

KNOWITALL's avatar

Never heard one political word from a pulpit. And ive gone to a wide variety in 51 years from AOG to Baptist to Catholic.

Caravanfan's avatar

Are you sure the word shouldn’t be “extort”? Vote my way or go to hell…

Blackberry's avatar

Obviously. Is it out of line? Do you think a corrupt organization has a “line”?

JLeslie's avatar

Even if the minister doesn’t directly say who to vote for, politics and who to vote for is implied and peer pressure exists in the congregation.

Mostly, it is that the Republican party markets to the Evangelicals and so religion and politics are tied together.

I have been in a church where the minister said it’s difficult to be a Christian today (during a wedding!) and it felt very political to me.

I have linked video before of Ted Cruz’s dad preaching to his congregation the constitution doesn’t say separation of church and state, the United States is supposed to have religion in government.

KNOWITALL's avatar

@JLeslie There are basic truths that most Christians agree on, so while it may not be spoken, its an assumption regarding political leanings. I mentioned in prior threads that one preacher joked about Adam & Steve from the pulpit and since that is not something I find funny, I never went back.
In my opinion a pastor leads the congregation from Gods word, not his own or the issue du jour.

JLeslie's avatar

@KNOWITALL Rafael Cruz was blatantly talking country and politics. I would think most churches are not doing that and only preach their truth according the beliefs and doctrine of the church.

However, that dinner and fashion show I went to in a mega church, the fashionista brought up abortion, which to me is very strange, but I rarely go to church.

Since abortion is constantly a big political topic, it seemed to me it was bringing up something political. It was framed as Jesus forgives you, but just odd to me. I think my friend found it helpful since she regretted an abortion she had, and I liked that it gave her solace, but also from another angle it seemed a way to recruit women too. I had mixed feelings about it.

I triggered my memory of playing with my friends young girls (elementary age) and while playing with barbie type dolls they came up with a skit about giving up a baby to adoption. I couldn’t help but wonder how often they hear adults, TV, or people in their church or religious school talking about that.

LifeQuestioner's avatar

Hi all, I just wanted to post an update after having gone to church this past week. Not one word was said about either candidate or even really about the results of the election. The sermon was on Psalm 20 which basically talks about David saying he doesn’t put his trust in horses or chariots (methods of fighting war back then), but rather that he puts his trust in the Lord. And the point of the sermon was that we should do the same, no matter who we voted for. That we are not supposed to look up to any one person, but to trust the Lord in all things.

I thought the sermon was very well done and spoke to both sides, no matter who you had voted for. As you can probably tell from my other posts, my candidate lost, but I really appreciated the sermon. And I do know that a number of people in the church voted for Trump, but I think the main thing for them was the abortion issue.

I have gingerly talked to a few people I know better and who I feel comfortable talking a bit of politics with. And many people said that they couldn’t vote for either candidate. They wouldn’t vote for Kamala because they felt abortion was wrong, but they would not vote for Trump either because of all his corruption.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther