General Question

Godlvall2's avatar

What does it mean when a girl pays for everything?

Asked by Godlvall2 (20points) November 24th, 2008

I’m just wondering what everyone thinks it means, or if there is a reason. She has paid for both me and her several times. I tried to pay at least for myself, but she wouldn’t have anything to do with it. I have some ideas, but I want to see what everyone has to say first.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

40 Answers

omfgTALIjustIMDu's avatar

I’m a girl and I pay for everything too (usually). There’s something about having someone else pay for me that seems like a put-down, or like I’m somehow indebted to them.

Likeradar's avatar

How long have you been seeing her? Are you actually seeing her or are you just friends?

Judi's avatar

Maybe she has control issues?

dynamicduo's avatar

It could mean that she has a lot of money and likes buying things for people. It could mean she has control issues. It could mean she dislikes traditional chivalry. Insist on paying next time and see what happens. If she freaks out… well that’s a bit of a warning sign.

Godlvall2's avatar

Just friends atm…seeing each other for a month or two.

It’s the fact that she insists on paying for me too, just makes me wonder.

Godlvall2's avatar

I did pay for her the other day, she said she owed me back and thanked me a bunch. It’s funny because I feel the same way when she pays for me. Could be control, but I don’t know.

Well I’m guessing a two things.
First, she likes me and wants to show it. and I already kinda know that
Second, someone suggested that she might have low self-esteem

It’s really not that big of an issue, I was just wondering if there was a clear set reason behind it.

Mr_M's avatar

You need to talk with her about it BEFORE you go out again.

Godlvall2's avatar

.@Mr M Why is that?

dynamicduo's avatar

There’s never a clear set reason for many things people do :)
In situations where I’m unsure of someone’s motive, I prefer to be blunt and ask them so as to minimize any misunderstandings. I suggest you bring it up in a non accusing way (“Hey, I was wondering about something…”), if you do want a final conclusive answer.

From all you’ve said I don’t see anything that jumps up as a red flag. Sometimes I (a girl) like paying for my friends both guys and girls because I make a decent chunk of change and can spare it whereas I may know things are tight for my friend.

Godlvall2's avatar

Alright,thank you.
If anyone else has any other comments/idea, I’ll check back later.

AlfredaPrufrock's avatar

Maybe she doesn’t want to be pressured into sex, and this is one way of having control of the relationship.

Godlvall2's avatar

LoL, maybe but that’s not what I’m interested in. I actually told her as much the other day. you could be right.

AlfredaPrufrock's avatar

Lurve to you, Godlvall2. Will you date my daughter if this doesn’t work out? She’ll let you pay. But she’s very low maintenance. Her idea of a date is watching the History Channel, going to the planetarium for the midnight show, or skateboarding

jsc3791's avatar

How about trying this:

Before you go out again – as in when you are making plans to go out – try saying “I’d love to do xyz with you but on one condition…I’d love it if you’d let me pay for the date. You’ve done so much already and I’d like to repay you.”

Do you think that is a plausible option?

dynamicduo's avatar

Great approach jsc3791.

mea05key's avatar

She owns you.

Godlvall2's avatar

@AlfredaPrufrock Sounds like you have a nice daughter. Honestly those all sound like awesome date ideas. I haven’t really had any girlfriends thus far, which sad considering I’m in college, need to get out there more Honestly might take you serious if your not careful! Hope she finds someone nice too.

@jsc3791 Indeed a nice approach. I’m going to talk/ask next time we are going to do something.

@mea05key Down-payment eh?

answerjill's avatar

If you are “just friends,” then I would say that the simplest thing would be for each of you to pay your own way, most of the time, anyway. Leave the confusion to the confusing world of dating!

squirbel's avatar

I am female. If I am dating a guy, and I still don’t allow him to pay for anything, it means that I don’t trust him to not pull the “I paid for this and now you owe me something, if you know what I mean” card. I rarely pay for both of us, though. I don’t want a deadbeat boyfriend. By the time I allow a guy to pay for my part of the date, that’s when I’ve started trusting him. :)

johnnyknoxville08's avatar

i envy you—what is that like!?!? i dated a girl for 3 years and had to pay for EVERYTHING. like if we went out to eat, i would order cheaper so i could still pay for hers.

enjoy it while you can, man!

mea05key's avatar

@godl

sort of. she pays now and her husband pays eveything for the rest of their life.

mea05key's avatar

at a brighter side, she loves you a lot. and she is willing to pay for reasonable stuffs. maybe again, she more loaded so she doesnt mind treating you. its not a bad thing. only thing that can be bad is you uncoutiously rely on her for expenses . try to make an effort to treat her also, talk to her about this. we are all only speculating

bythebay's avatar

Maybe she she just doesn’t want you to carry the burden of cost. Perhaps you two could agree to simply take turns? At least she sounds considerate.

Godlvall2's avatar

@johnknoxvill08 I shall, but I won’t take advantage of it. Meh, I don’t know how to really describe her yet.
@squirbel Honestly I don’t have any problem with the “I’ll pay my half”, that’s fine with me. I do like paying for both of us sometimes.
@mea05key That’s a dramatic way of thinking of it. Defiantly think far into the future.

Godlvall2's avatar

@bythebay That’s what I’m going to aim for. However, I would like to treat her occasionally.

TheBox193's avatar

Your such a nerd. It really doesn’t matter that much.

answerjill's avatar

@TheBox, that is not very nice.

dynamicduo's avatar

Yes, there’s no such thing as a dumb question… only a dumb answer :|

Godlvall2's avatar

It’s alright, don’t worry about him.

Mtl_zack's avatar

i have a similar situation. actually, very similar. the girl who im friends/i dunno with is very independent. she had things in her past that affect how she sees independence. she thinks that when you’re in debt, you have to pay the person back. try en-debting yourself to her, so that you owe her the money, and you buy her whatever it is you’re buying. like say, “thanks for getting me out of the house tonight. my family is kinda crazy. i owe you one”, or “thanks for helping me with my assignment, to make up for it, let me buy your ticket”. stuff like that.

another alternative is do stuff that is free. dont announce that its free before you go, because you’ll sound cheap. when you show up, go to the counter and ask for a ticket, the clerk will reply saying its free, and you go on your date.

tiggersmom's avatar

There could be several reasons for it. She could be wealthy, and just expects to do that all the time, or she is trying to show you that she will take care of you. Or she is just extremely indepenent, and won’t let anyone take care of her for anything. But, the only way that you will find out for sure is to talk to her about it. Hope this helps.

Mr_M's avatar

I STILL say talk to her about it before the next date. Tell her “Can we talk”? Then say “You keep paying for everything and I’m not comfortable with that. Why do you do it? I don’t WANT you to do it. When we go out I like the idea of ME taking you out. ME GIVING YOU the night out is a gift from me to you and like any gift, it’s not a gift if the OTHER person pays for it…” and take it from there.

This is assuming you don’t want her to pay all the time and, as the gentleman, you would not.

dynamicduo's avatar

I think you’re right about the talking before the next date, because as I’ve said before, I prefer to have clarification if situations are sketchy. But I think you’ve veered way into the fantasy gentleman direction. Which might be right for some, but can also be a turn-off to others such as myself I prefer gentlemen to express their gentleness in other ways than simply paying the bill. Personally I don’t much like the idea of a man saying he’s taking ME out, HE’S giving me the night out like its some type of present only he has to give. WE are going out together to have fun, I pay for you sometimes but you pay for me too, we’re equal. I would stop at your first two lines, ending at “Why do you do it?” and let her answer before getting into your slightly lecture-toned reasonings.

Mr_M's avatar

I admit, I’m “old school”! I feel the presence of her company is the way the woman contributes her part of the date. Then I don’t feel guilty when we’re making out passionately in the back seat of the car! :)

tiggersmom's avatar

@thebox193, that really wasn’t nice at all. You should apologize for that.

CodyM's avatar

Consider the cost factor. The male is supposed be a gentleman, and treat the female like the royalty she is. Gentlemen pay up to show she costs something. If she doesn’t cost you something, she isn’t worth as much to you as she should. Weather it be your money, time, or attention. Treat her like she’s supposed to be treated, pay for her. If the girl can’t let a guy pay for her, she’s got issues. Either with independence, acceptance or control. She feels like she’s independent, so he shouldn’t have to pay for her. Or she has acceptance issues, feeling like she can’t accept gifts from anyone(or certain people). Or she has control issues, which is basically the whole independence thing.
Guys: pay up, show her shes worth it.
Girls: accept it, realise he’s showing you that you’re worth something to him, and treat him great.

My 2 cents

TheBox193's avatar

Thank you CodyM, that was interesting. Do you think that guy always have to take on this cost? What about this feminism and ‘flattening’ of gender roles? Would it be fair if the female were to do the opposite for the guy, that is pay for him and he should accept it because he is worth something to her? aka is the reverse true too? Is it alright for the woman to be the ‘gentlewoman’?

I believe in chivalry, I respect women, I always try to treat the well (which doesn’t seem to get me far, but never mind that). I apologize godlvall2, I was just messing around, I’m starting to think the gentleman approach isn’t the way to go, it’s dead, doesn’t work. They don’t really pay attention, they don’t really care, just another “nice guy’. They think it’s cute… yay…that…nice, maybe? I’m getting derailed and depressed.
Whatever.

CodyM's avatar

Hey TheBox193, I understand what you’re saying. About feminism and the change in gender roles. And I agree that the female should show that the male means something to her, but not necessarily with money, and in her own special ways.
I was raised with the belief that the male is the head of the household, and the primary financial provider.
This is because the female has one of the hardest jobs on earth: being a mother. She needs to know that her male can provide for her while she takes care of the family. And I strongly believe this is why my parents have the amazing relationship that they have today. I’ve literally never heard my parents go off on each other, or even had the inkling of divorce in our home. Their love for each other showed us a very obvious picture of what a home should be like.
As I grew up, I learned one very important fact about parenting: One of the greatest things parents can do for their children is to love each other. My parents both played their key roles: my father the provider, my mother the nurturer.
Just some background on where I’m coming from.

Now to answer your questions from my point of view:

Do you think that guy always have to take on this cost?
Not 100% of the time, no. For me–at first–it is very important to establish her in your mind as someone that is worth your time, and specifically, money. After being together a while, you will form your own relationship based around finances. I’ll use me and my girlfriend as an example: At first, I would pay for everything. This includes nice dinners, outings, movies, whatever. After months of dating, she said very plainly that she didn’t want me to pay for absolutely everything, especially if whatever we were doing was her idea. If we went to a movie she wanted to see, sometimes she would pay. If we went biking, which was my idea, I would pay for the drinks & food that came after. etc etc.

What about this feminism and ‘flattening’ of gender roles?
My opinion is very clear. I am 100% for women as equals. There was never any difference, society just clued into this for some reason :P But I think there’s a difference between feminism and being a very strong & influential woman, and their outcomes and consequences. I’ve seen some women do amazing things, never asking to be treated equal. Yet I’ve seen some feminist activists that protest day and night to be treated equal, but get nowhere. The protest I’m talking about is figurative, they’re not actually walking around with signs and stuff.
In my future, I want a woman that knows I will be there for her 100%. Weather it’s financial support, or emotional, I’m there. If there’s only 1 woman out of 100,000,000 that is like that, I would go for her, instead of the lot. I’d rather someone who will never waiver in love and trust, than someone who will wake up one day and decide she isn’t in love anymore because I’m not making as much as she is.

Would it be fair if the female were to do the opposite for the guy, that is pay for him and he should accept it because he is worth something to her?
Yes. But as I said before–in my point of view–this will come after the initial romancing. I would never ask a girl out to a movie and not pay. Or take her to a nice restaurant and make her pay the $90+ bill. That just screams douchebag.

As for your comments about chivalry. I think the term has always been a bit overused, and ended up being ‘dead’. I try hard to treat everyone I know with great respect and honor, not just women. I’m pretty sure anyone with common sense can see right through bad intentions. As long as your intentions behind your actions are true, you shouldn’t have any problem.
I don’t believe that there’s just one person for everyone. That would basically mean, it would just take 1 person to screw up the entire grand scheme. I strongly believe that you find someone you are willing to work for, and keep. For some it’s easier find, for some it’s harder to keep. For some it’s harder to find, and easier to keep. I think your chivalry is honorable, and your respect for women to be held with the highest esteem. Those women you talk about, the ones who don’t pay attention, the ones who don’t really seem to care. I think the only question you need to ask yourself is this:
Are you sure you’re wanting someone like that?
Cause honestly, it sounds like you’re trying to please women that obviously don’t get it. I say this out of experience: look for the 1 in the 100,000,000. You’ll find her. And she’ll treat far greater than any of those other women could ever conceive.

Sorry for the long post, but I hope this helps.

Again, this is just from what I’ve learned and grown up believing, and it’s been working out very well for me so far. I have an amazing, successful girlfriend. Amazing, loving parents. And amazingly awesome friends.

Life’s pretty good once you figure it out =]

musician210's avatar

I’am a married guy and my wife left to be with her mom…met this older woman 6 years older than me, she is married and lives with her husband. We see each other and everytime we go out she pays for everything, the food, my cell phone bill, the motel. I really am not used to this since I have been the one always paying when I was married and when I wasnt married and dating before I had always paid. This lady is really crazy about me, and I just love the attention she is giving me she is also hot too. I told her joking I wanted to go to the beach and she told me we were going to go now. I’am like wow. Really would like to know if anyone has had that experience or something similar and what you all think?

Lonesomewoe's avatar

Maybe she is a working girl.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther