@galileogirl – to be honest, I think you have an incredibly negative view of one of the largest and most successful social networking sites on the planet, simply based on hearsay and your own judgement calls.
The ‘time’ committment is a good demonstration of this. I recieve four, maybe five notifications from Facebook via e-mail every day. Notifications that a friend has listed me in one of their photo albums, has posted me a message, has invited to me to a social event, etc. It takes me all of two minutes to respond to one of these posts, ironically much less time than if that person were to phone, text or sometimes even e-mail me to let me know of these happenings.
Should it replace real-life conversations and communications? No. Is anyone suggesting that? No. You’ve assumed this community / service has supplanted real life, as opposed to augmenting it – which is the reason that Niki and others are expressing dismay at the possibility of no longer being able to use it for mass-communication to include a friend who’s having to ‘hide’ (essentially) from the situation that has arisen.
Other problems with your argument are essentially that you’ve made basic errors in assumption of how Facebook functions. If a study group were meeting, there would probably be an invite waiting for you upon login, or a quick use of Facebook’s powerful search facility would soon turn it up. As for hunting for happenings and gossip, much of this is eliminated by the use of a news feed in which recent events and most things that are noteworthy find their way to you.
I think, to be blunt, you are very well informed but not having used or closely investigated the service being discussed has unfortunately rendered some hostile reactions (and I’m sorry if mine has come across that way, as ironically I’m all about maintaining real life contacts and relationships in this overly tech-obsessed world also). Hopefully even this topic has helped dispel some of the myths for you.
Just to also mention, Facebook is becoming less and less of a ‘Generation Txt’ commodity, and I’m happy to say my parents use it to communicate with friends they’ve lost touch with, and harness its various other uses to further relationships and keep in touch.
Any service that encourages the sharing of thoughts, communication and promoting relationships and social events, with a low barrier to user interaction and a critical mass such as Facebook’s, should be commended highly!