I love listening to the chiropractic discussion. Here is my experience.
I’ve been to a chiropractor before. It’s this place actually. I’ve had discussions with my regular chiropractor there many times about me being skeptical about chiropractic. But this guy is not a quack that believes all causes are caused by a crooked spine, and that he can heal anything with his magical hands. He’s a guy that believes that it’s important to have a well balanced spine because 1) it’s the nerve road to your brain, if the road gets pinched or pressured, problems can occur, and 2) our bones do change as we age, the discs between vertebrae can get damaged and wear down over time and usage and it’s better for them to be aligned than not aligned.
I started going there in my teens when I was having strange undiagnosable problems (a long story). We went through a gradually decreasing regimen of treatments and examining to correct imbalances in my spine. Ultimately, I cannot say whether his treatment helped me, but it certainly did not harm me at all. At the end of the treatment my back was pretty well aligned as shown by their neato evaluation device, electrode based I believe, I know he explained it to me when I asked but I’ve forgotten now.
I went there a few years ago when I had hurt myself running for the train. He did a new evaluation, suggested a simple treatment schedule (which fit into my mom’s insurance limits, of course) and we completed it. Again, I was back to normal by the end of the treatment but I can’t know whether he had an effect or not.
My dad had a lot of back problems and was treated by the same doctor. My dad is now out and geocaching all day, hiking in the woods and scampering around. Again, did chiropractic help? I’ve asked him and he does think that it did help, and he’s the biggest skeptic I know (he had seriously bad back pain too).
One thing I do know is that my doctor was extremely respectful of the situations, never pressed unnecessary treatment, would offer any help or explanation of anything (and I was a curious kid, so I asked a lot), and was in general one of the kindest and sympathetic doctors I have met to date.
Based on my experiences so far, I am not ready to discredit chiropractic completely without further evidence that the style I have been shown, the more respectful style, causes damage other than to the pocketbook.
Also to note is that I’m Canadian with Canadian insurance, so my mom’s work covered 90% of the costs of all of the treatments, and the chiropractic office took strides to make sure we were scheduled for what the insurance covered. Then again, all doctors and dentists here tend to do that, it’s just one consequence of the system we have.
I just exited a stretch of back pain recently, and my work insurance covers a chunk of chiropractic per year, so maybe I’ll go for an evaluation to see how out of whack my spine is now.