General Question

YARNLADY's avatar

Why do people ask questions that say "How do you" (do this) when they really mean "How can I do it"?.

Asked by YARNLADY (46587points) April 6th, 2009

It’s confusing to me, because I never know if they want to know how I do it, or if they want advice on how they can do it.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

7 Answers

EmpressPixie's avatar

Because they want to know how YOU do it so that they can adapt it to something they can do. Or just figure out if it is something they can do at all—like, if they even have a chance at doing it.

dynamicduo's avatar

Well, it’s also a result of the general collapse of English language integrity.

Jayne's avatar

In a way, the phrase seems to be a mild flattery. It recognizes that they have an ability that you lack, and is mildly self-deprecating; depending on how you say it, it often carries a note of exasperation with yourself. In short, it makes the helper feel good, as though they have something to offer and are not simply being called upon as the nearest person at hand. This is not always the case, now that the usage has become standard, but I imagine that this is at least part of its origins.

dynamicduo's avatar

It could also be a result of the younger generation (and other internetty folk) using such a form to get answers from Google. For instance, I get more hits (and totally different results, I will note) when I search for “how do you make a pie shell” versus “how does one make a pie shell”. Extending this, many article writers use terms like “How to improve your sex life in 10 easy steps” versus “How one would improve their sex life using these 10 simple steps”.

MrItty's avatar

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/you

2. one; anyone; people in general: ‘a tiny animal you can’t even see.’

“How do you do this” means “How does one do this”, not “How does the person I am speaking to do this”.

Jeruba's avatar

Exactly, @MrItty. What they really mean is “How does one do this?” (equivalent to “man” in German, as “Wie macht man das?”), or “How is this done?” The way we say that colloquially in English is with “you.”

Jeruba's avatar

Incidentally, one of the rules on WikiAnswers is that such questions must be written with “you,” presumably to get more hits because they’re expected to be worded that way in searches.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther