I totally agree with CAK that the two are not the same thing. Sometimes they are comorbid, but I think that’s rare. By the way, @hungryhungryhortence, bipolar disorder is the same as manic-depression. There is an argument in the community about which is the more politically correct term. Some call it bipolar disorder because it makes it sound more real and medical. Some prefer to call it manic-depression because that is very descriptive about what it is.
The interesting thing, I’ve found, about ADD, is that I work very well with them, and with OCD folk. It might be just me, but my theory is that ADD folk can’t see the forest for the trees, and they need to know what to focus on. Bipolar folk can’t see the trees for the forest. They see the overall picture, and get grandiose ideas about it, but that can’t follow through and make it happen. Put an ADD with a Bipolar, and you get a team that can’t be beat. Or so I think.
Anyway, obviously I believe in the diseases. I believe they are organic. I believe they are tricky to diagnose, and even trickier to treat. I don’t think there are drug company conspiracies to encourage doctors and psychiatrists to find more cases than are really there. These are not terribly interesting issues.
The real interesting issue is the last one. Are drugs that control how people think or act moral or immoral?
Now see, here’s an ADD person spraying around questions, and not knowing which is the important one, and here’s a bipolar person setting straight the priorities. That doesn’t mean I’m right about the priorities, but it’s just illustrative of the interaction between our two types.
I’ve asked this question many a time. It is very disconcerting to take a drug and have it change, not only what you feel, and not just the way you think, but also the thoughts you have! It makes you realize how much your mental states and thoughts are determined by chemicals. It makes you realize that if the technology is suffiently advanced, we may, one day, be able to take a drug in order to become a math whiz, or a diplomat, or a great musician.
If it’s moral to fix a problem, how can it be immoral to enhance an ability? Students already use ritalin to help them study. It helps them stay alert longer (it’s an amphetamine), and it keeps them focused.
So, is it moral to relieve mental pain? Is it moral to save a life by changing the personality and the thoughts a person thinks?
When I first experienced the impact of these drugs, I was a little freaked about it. I wondered who was I? The me before I took the medicine, or the me after? The me after was like the me I remembered, but wasn’t the me who did all those horrible things while I was manic still me? I think so. I hurt a lot of people when I was sick, and I am very sorry for that. If I could have seen what I was doing with the eyes I have now, I don’t think I would have done those things.
I got virtually (as in over the internet) involved with many women, while “sick,” and hurt most of them. Some of them blamed themselves for my behavior, and believed they should have known better than to get involved with someone like me. One even thought she made me sicker. Well, I think I was responsible for all the decisions I made while “sick” but it’s confusing, because I know that if I had been like I am now, I never would have made those decisions. I can’t go back to change the past. All I can say is that I’m sorry, and try to explain as best I can.
Anyway, I struggled with which was me—the sick me or the not-sick me. Harp suggested they are both me, and I think that makes sense. I think that just as we give people vaccines for flu viruses so they don’t infect other people, it is correct to give mentally ill people medicine so they don’t hurt more people. So they can become productive again.
Yes, we are changing their personalities. We are taking away their extreme behavior. We are reigning them in. But we live in a social society. People have to get along. We don’t necessarily do society any favors by allowing such extreme behavior to exist. We pay for that, though. If we reign in the bipolar folk or the ADD folk, who knows how many brilliant ideas we will lose? Ideas that could make a huge difference for society, or humankind.
It is for that reason, that many sick people choose not to be medicated. I think that’s fine. It should be up to us to choose what kind of person we want to be—which of our alternate selves. I choose to be medicated because I don’t want to die; I don’t want to leave my kids fatherless; I don’t want to cheat on my wife; I don’t want to hurt the other people who get involved with me. I think those are pretty moral reasons to be treated.