We need always consider carefully the nature of our assistance.
I agree with this statement.
But I also believe your basic premise that giving handouts on the street increases homelessness or alcoholism among the homeless is really quite absurd. It leads me to want to ask the following question: Have you ever known any homeless people?
I would also like to point out that missions fill up and run out of food. Social services do run dry. There absolutely is not always help available. And sometimes that money is enough to make up for the lack of services.
And to add to that, mental health services, which is what many homeless people need are even less available. So we are essentially setting people up to be homeless by denying them access to needed services. If you would deny them handouts as well, well then really I think this reasoning is a way to overcome some guilt.
Regardless of either of our opinions the facts don’t add up either way. You are right in saying the money could be spent elsewhere and have a greater effect. But that does not change the need for daily assistance when the wells run dry . Can you imagine living on no money? Really there is no evidence that suggests one is contributing to the cause by giving handouts. And there is none that say it helps either. Of course I’ve met and known homeless people and work in low-income housing. Handouts do help if only for giving hope that people give a sh*t.
Coming straight from the horse’s mouth:
It’s a myth that panhandlers do pretty well for themselves, Connery said.
“The people who panhandle are homeless, are poor, have issues and they need help,” he said.
Eighty-one percent of the 107 panhandlers surveyed separately said they were homeless, and 70 percent said they had a disabling condition.
Goodland, 45, said he is disabled and hasn’t been able to find a job that pays enough to put a roof over his head.
Goodland said if people stopped giving him handouts near the freeway, he still wouldn’t spend much time in a homeless shelter.
“You can only stay in them a certain amount of time,” he said. “It’s seven days here, three days there. I’d still be back on the street. I want a place to live, but I want to do it on my own.
Food Pantry Shuts Down
Another Food Pantry Shuts Down
Not Enough Mental Health Servcies
I suppose we are going to have to agree to disagree. Or just plain disagree.
Of course that is no excuse for making offensive comments.