General Question

Facade's avatar

Do you think that if the economy doesn't get back on its feet, we will resort back to a legal barter system at least partially?

Asked by Facade (22937points) July 24th, 2009
Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

16 Answers

Judi's avatar

I have been bartering for years to some extent. You should see my pearly white veneers and the beautiful kitchen my dentist has! (Hubby is a contractor.)

CMaz's avatar

Nope, after the revolution. Things will come back to “normal”.

YARNLADY's avatar

Many of us have been doing that all along. It won’t be anything to go ‘back’ to.

dalepetrie's avatar

By legal, what do you mean exactly? Bartering is still perfectly legal, always has been and always will be. If you wonder if people will resort to it more, yes, it’s already happening. But money came about because things got too complex. It was one thing when societies pretty much just had food and clothing for needs, you had one person who could make clothes and another who could gather or kill food, you’d trade with each other. But there are literally billions of things people need and want in our society and bartering is not, nor could it ever again become (without a complete break down of our society and a massive cleansing of the population through disease, war, the rapture or some other method) a viable means of people trading one skill for another. No one person who would require the things I would be able to provide out of whole cloth could possibly meet every one of my needs, therefore they need to give me something for my efforts which I can use to seek out providers of each thing I need…such is what money is about. Even countries which experience bad problems with their monetary systems….first off their banks will declare bank holidays, take back all the old money and put into circulation new money (for example, you have hyperinflation, you don’t want to have to carry around a 1,000,000,000,000,000,000 bill to buy milk, so the government will make 1,000,000,000,000,000,000 in old currency equal to 100,000 in new currency and have you bring your money in to trade. Or in some really depressed countries where money becomes next to worthless, what they have often done is to use another currency…like people in certain countries will only accept Euros or US dollars, even though they’re not the currency of the nation in which they live…it’s a hedge against the declining value of a dollar.

But this has never gone away and will only get more and more popular as people have less and less money to spend, even a few years ago when things weren’t nearly as bad as they were now, my wife joined an internet service allowing people to swap books…you’d put books on that you had, and if someone requested one, you’d ship it to them, you’d pay for the postage, but you’d get so many credits for that book. Then you could take that credit and have someone else send you a book off their list. But even that form of bartering required sort of an intermediary, something akin to money (in this case, credits). And what about that guy a few years back who decided that maybe he could trade a paper clip for a house. He wanted a house, so he took a paper clip and saw what people would trade him for it. He picked the best offer, then traded that for the best thing he could get, and so on, and so forth…I think eventually he got a walk on role in a film, and someone really wanted that and they traded him for a house, or something for which he was able to trade a house.

I think it will become more of a necessity for some people, but cash will ALWAYS be king.

The_Compassionate_Heretic's avatar

Barter and trade only works on a small scale which is not realistic in a country as large as the US.

BBSDTfamily's avatar

I hope not, because I have nothing to barter.

The_Compassionate_Heretic's avatar

Also, bartering will create hoarding which would result in exploitation worse than anything most Americans have ever experienced. There’s no regulation in bartering.

Zendo's avatar

Bartering will be fun and much better than the system under which we now live.

YARNLADY's avatar

@BBSDTfamily Bartering doesn’t have to be physical objects. You could barter an hour of tutoring, or reading to an elderly person, in exchange for a gallon of gas, or similar. Bartering is an exchange of anything between two people who agree on the value.

marinelife's avatar

Not in the mainstream.

YARNLADY's avatar

As I said above, to my way of thinking we have never gotten away from bartering. I have had many a live in housekeeper in exchange for room and board, pet sitters exchange my vacation for theirs, friends bring their computers over and share their skills and tips with each other, the Food Bank gives away donated food to people who agree to work there, the Habitat for Humanity program gives away free houses in exchange for ‘sweat equity’, we have ride sharing to and from work, Senior Gleaners pick up left over fruit, and come out to our home to get our excess vegetables, I make costumes for people in exchange for all kinds of different things.

Response moderated
YARNLADY's avatar

No, mine are more in line with the Middle Ages/Renaissance. I did design a wolf costurme once, and a fish for my grandson. Some of my fantasy designs won a costume contest.

Zendo's avatar

@YARNLADY
Thanks for the tiny print. As if it is not hard enough reading this blue on blue stuff…LOL

YARNLADY's avatar

@Zendo on my computer, I just push the “Ctrl +” and it gets bigger

Zendo's avatar

@YARNLADY if it’s not one thing it’s another! :)

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther