General Question

DominicX's avatar

Do your musical tastes clash or mainly fit with those of your partner?

Asked by DominicX (28808points) July 25th, 2009

I was just wondering because I was thinking about the fact that my parents pretty much have the same musical interests. While some of the music I like (mainly the mainstream R&B, hip hop, rock, and pop) might go along with another person’s, a lot of the music I like is kind of strange and uncommon (classical, new age, bubblegum dance, musical music, etc.) and anyone who was with me would have to know that sometimes I would play music like this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tLMClvlO3Ic&feature=related

So, those of you in a relationship (or referring to past relationships), do your musical tastes clash, are they exactly the same, are they partly the same, mostly the same, a little bit the same, etc. and how has that worked out for you?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

50 Answers

DeanV's avatar

Nah. Me and my left hand get along pretty well.

dannyc's avatar

The total opposite. But I still believe all music and artistry has value so I try and give it a whirl, even if not my cup of tea.

tinyfaery's avatar

For the most part we share musical tastes. She likes a bit country and hip hop, and I still love my cheesy 80’s stuff, but we just listen to it when we are alone.

Grisaille's avatar

That link made my ears not feel good. And I only played 4 seconds.

aprilsimnel's avatar

Wow, they all clashed. One ex did like R.E.M., though, and introduced me to a band I like now called Regurgitator, but mainly, no, the musical tastes of my exes and I all were very different from each other.

Facade's avatar

Our musical tastes are mainly the same. Although, he likes to listen to rap and hip hop, and I detest that degrading garbage.

Grisaille's avatar

@Facade You better be talking about the new shit, else we’re fightin’.

Facade's avatar

@Grisaille I know nothing of the old school stuff so yea, I guess that’s what I’m talking about

DominicX's avatar

@Grisaille

Oh, it’s the best song ever. I love music from Denmark.

evelyns_pet_zebra's avatar

My wife likes oldies, and Elvis, and older country, and Wayne Newton and stuff like that. She also really likes Aerosmith. I like classical, jazz, R&B, some blues, some rock, and the occasional 80’s rock/alternative. She will listen to my music, but I rarely listen to hers. We do both like Meatloaf and Melissa Etheridge and some other bands from the 90’s, though.

That link had me looking for dancing cartoon cats drawn in the Pokemon style.

Grisaille's avatar

@DominicX Hey, to each his own. Just don’t think you’re coming on the Fluther roadtrip expecting to play that shit in my car. You’re getting thrown out the window at 60 MPH.

@Facade * squints eyes * I’m watchin’ you.

Tink's avatar

Mines do, cause I can’t stand some type of music, so if he’s gonna be playing it all the time I better like it…

kheredia's avatar

My bf has been a big musical influence in my life. There’s a lot of music that I didn’t know of before I met him. I’ve introduced him to some of my favorite artists just as he has introduced me to some of his. We compliment each other on that aspect.

DominicX's avatar

@Grisaille

See, most of my friends play innocuous mainstream R&B, hip hop, rock, and pop in their cars. Doesn’t bother me. But if one of them decides to play screamo, emo, or some other ear-bleeding-inducing crap, then I will volunteer to jump out of the car at 60 MPH. That hasn’t happened yet, though. Animal Collective is about as different as I’ve heard from my friends and I love Animal Collective. I really only play my “secret songs” when I’m alone (either at home or in my car).

Luckily Rory doesn’t really like rock. Neither do I. It works great. :)

kenmc's avatar

I’d say it’s a 60/40 split favoring similarity.

There’s plenty that she likes and I don’t and vice-versa.

hungryhungryhortence's avatar

Mainly fit. It’s a thrill to be able to have music playing near 24/7 and not worry about the playlists.

Grisaille's avatar

@DominicX I’m just joshin’. I’m actually quite liberal in my musical tastes and can tolerate (and even enjoy) pretty much anything.

Yes, even country. And screamo. And house music.

DominicX's avatar

See, I don’t see much wrong with country. It’s not exactly my “thing”, but it doesn’t make me angry like it seems to do for other people. I just find it kind of boring. I do have two songs, one of them being Taylor Swift, if that counts as country. :P

But screamo…even the name is whiny…makes me angry… ;)

Grisaille's avatar

It is a horrid name.

Tink's avatar

@DominicX Ha then I can see me and you won’t get along :P

hug_of_war's avatar

He can at least tolerate most of my music and likes a little of it, and while I won’t listen to his type of music on my own, I don’t really mind it and occasionally I quite enjoy it.

Alleycat8782's avatar

My ex and I both love rock music. He introduced to me to many more modern/alternative rock bands that I am in love with now.

However, I do enjoy heavy rock maybe a little screamo in there. Also, for some odd reason I LOVE 80s music- he really doesn’t lol.

For the most part having the same interests in music really helped in our relationship. We would go to concerts together, talk about music, and listen to it together. Now I think if he liked country (which I highly dislike) I don’t think I could relate to him at all.

jamielynn2328's avatar

My husband likes punk and I find it degrading. He likes hard rock, classic rock and some metal, and that hurts my innards.

I like ska, reggae, funk and some indie…

We do not get along musically at all. We do both enjoy some adult contemporary and the Beatles, Sublime and Weezer so at least we have a small slice of common ground.

DominicX's avatar

@jamielynn2328

Yay Weezer! An example of one of the few rock bands that I like. Weezer is just awesome.

Inofaith's avatar

Well, in my previous relationship we shared a few musical genres, that was good for visiting live concerts or festivals together.
But also we had our very own distinct tastes (the bigger part of it).

I think it’s better if you and your partner have different tastes. Music is very personal and defines part of you as a person, if your partner would like exactly the same music as you do… that would be annoying.
Both liking other music can inspire the other; when my (ex) girfriend came with “hey have you heard this song?!” I was always like, wow how did you find that stuff… And sometimes I thought it was great, in some cases I didn’t like it and she could still have her own songs as I did mine.
“our song” was Smoke City – Underwater Love :)

—I’d like to add: I make music, and my girlfriend was very neutral about it. She never really said if she liked or disliked my music. She just liked the fact I am passionate about something.
And that was great. It sort of made clear that she was with me because of me, and not because of whatever it is that I do.—

El_Cadejo's avatar

She likes almost everything I like and vice versa. I seem to actively seek out new music more than her though.

augustlan's avatar

We have some odd intersections (Delbert McClintock, Johnny Cash, Jackson Browne, Nora Jones) but for the most part we enjoy different music. He’s nine years older than I am, so we grew up in distinctly different musical eras (him 70s, me 80s). Plus he’s a bit of a dinosaur (Anything new is bad! Only the old stuff is good!), while I still listen to current music in addition to that from my own era. I’ll listen to most of his stuff (though not when he’s in an ‘all country, all the time’ mood), but I rock out considerably harder than him and he doesn’t really enjoy most of my stuff. That’s what driving alone in the car is for anyway. ;)

Saturated_Brain's avatar

It’s complicated right now.. I’m technically single, but I’m considering getting back together in the future.. That leaves me in a kind of limbo..

But to answer the question, it’s a kinda mix. We do share quite a lot of common ground. The Corrs for one, same for classical music and some jazz and some pop. But to be honest we still haven’t really totally explored each other’s musical tastes (it’s uncharted territory there).

As for that link in your question… Please never ever ever play that again. It reeks of bubblegum

Although I do like this a lot..

DominicX's avatar

@Saturated_Brain

Yep, Aqua, Toy Box, Ni-Ni, Creamy, Daze, all Danish bubblegum dance bands. I love bubblegum dance. Makes me feel so happy. :)

OpryLeigh's avatar

Our music tastes are mostly very different. There are a few things we agree on (we both like certain R&B artistes for example and he also appreciates my love of Dusty Springfield) but other than that he makes fun of me about a lot of the music I love (in a nice way). He will put up with some of it but there are certain things (Cher and Meat Loaf for example) that he will REFUSE to listen to!

allansmithee's avatar

My music taste is almost definitely going to clash with my partner in when I’m older, I maybe have a chance of not clashing if he’s really camp.

@DominicX
That music taste makes you camp enough for me :)

cookieman's avatar

This is one of the few things that truly bugs me about my relationship with my wife.

I am a huge music fan – into many different genres. I try to learn a lot about the artists through articles and interviews and I love listening to live music.

My wife is completely apathetic towards music. She couldn’t tell one artist from another if her life depended on it. She doesn’t own a single album (physical or digital). The radio in her car is never on and she doesn’t own an iPod.

If I play music, she always asks me to turn it down to a whisper. so I’ve stopped bothering

Over the years, I’ve tried introducing her to various artists to no avail.

She could not care less. It, frankly, bothers me a great deal because music is such an important part of my life.

Inofaith's avatar

@cprevite Hm, I feel sorry for you. I have never heard of someone who doesn’t like music.
I was under the assumption that every human being has some prehistoric tribal affection with rhythm sound and tonality built-in.

So she really doesn’t have any music in her life whatsoever?
I hope you can still enjoy your passion with friends.

cookieman's avatar

@Inofaith: Yup, as I said. She’s apathetic towards it. Every once in a blue moon she’ll hear a song on television and tell me she likes it. I’ll download it for her, but she’ll never listen to it again.

But it doesn’t impede my ability to enjoy music.

Inofaith's avatar

@cprevite : ok, well I’m glad you can have a relation despite this fact.
For me personally it would be a problem if the person that I would be in love with had nothing with music.
(Being a musician it’s a fact you can’t neglect)

knitfroggy's avatar

My husband and I both listen to a lot of the same music. We both listen to a lot of classic rock-the Doors, Led Zeppelin, Rolling Stones, etc. But we also both listen to a lot of stuff that the other can’t stand. When he’s downstairs on his computer listening to Jethro Tull and the rock flute I could explode after a while, it drives me insane. I yell down the stairs “Put on your headset! I can’t stand it anymore!” And he isn’t so crazy about my Damien Rice and Michael Jackson. But for the most part we agree on most music.

jbfletcherfan's avatar

We clash. I like the oldies & soft rock. He likes old & new country. God, I can’t STAND it! But he’ll listen to the oldies, too. When we’re in my car, we listen to my station. When we’re in his truck, I turn the volume down, ha. Country makes my teeth hurt!

Darwin's avatar

We both like oldies, and he ignores everything else I listen to.

Inofaith's avatar

I liked it when my ex girlfriend and I where cooking, id ask her to put on some music. Almost always was a fine pick. Enjoyed the new sounds she gave.

jonsblond's avatar

Music is very important to me and my husband. Our love of music and the fact that we have very similar interests was part of our initial attraction to each other. We both played the same instruments as teenagers and he still plays the guitar. I’m hoping to learn one of these days.

There’s not much music out there that we don’t enjoy. We used to say “We like everything but country” but the two of us enjoy some of it now. Older country, not the newer stuff. I think the only time we do clash is when we are spending time outdoors and he wants to listen to music but I would rather listen to “nature’s music”. Whenever this happens we make sure that we each get an equal amount of time to listen to what we want.

El_Cadejo's avatar

@jonsblond bah your outdoors that means NO ELECTRONIC DEVICES. I think im going to have to have a talk with your hubby :P

jonsblond's avatar

@uberbatman You would love the people we camp with. They have four televisions in their RV. My husband and sons got to play Guitar Hero when we camped in Colorado. Really “roughing it” isn’t it! :P

El_Cadejo's avatar

@jonsblond CAMPING!?! that is NOT camping. I hate faux camping >_<. Just give me a tent, a sleeping bag, and a bag of something else, and im good to go :P

jonsblond's avatar

@uberbatman I’d rather camp with you! We were the only ones who slept in a tent when the rest of the group slept in their RVs. We were also stuck listening to top 40 country. :(

El_Cadejo's avatar

@jonsblond omg im so sorry. Not only music but country music….. wow that really sucks.

Hambayuti's avatar

My hubby is just 2 years older than me but he’s more into ballad/romantic songs. I listen to every type of music. However, if there’s a song playing which we both like, we sing out loud with it and laugh at each other (‘cause we’re both usually out of tune. haha)

Darwin's avatar

@uberbatman Don’t you want a shovel, too?

dalepetrie's avatar

My wife and I complimented each other quite nicely…that’s how I like to think about it. She is about a year and a half older than I am, so we basically grew up with the same popular music, and it seems where we retained any affinity for the kinds of music on the top 40, we tended to be into mostly the same things, which of course by and large were the same things that were popular with just about anyone. Regarding music that came before our era, namely the classic rock and oldies (or what was called oldies at the time), we certainly seem to appricate the same things, the only real difference is that my wife was exposed to a lot of the classic rock, the 70s hard rock and such, not that long after it came out…she grew up with adult role models who listened to that kind of music. I didn’t start discovering bands like Zeppelin, The Who, Skynyrd, etc. until I was about 15, because my mom listened to oldies and country exclusively…I wasn’t really into the country, but I liked the oldies, and it wasn’t until the early 80s when I was 11 or 12 years old before I first checked out FM radio and found out about top 40 via Michael Jackson, Prince, Madonna, etc., and it wasn’t until 3 or so years later that the one classic rock station about 85 miles from my house boosted its signal enough so I could receive it up in the boondocks. Once I did, I got turned on to the stuff she’d known about for some time. Now our classic rock station would play some artists who bordered on college/alternative music, people like the Smithereens or the Church or INXS, whom I would have found out about anyway a couple years later when Kick came out. But most of what I had exposure to was what was really popular in the late 80s…hair metal. Now I liked some of it, my wife never got into it, she actually lived in a big city, had MTV and watched 120 minutes…she knew about all this great music I was missing out on because there were no radio stations where I lived that played it, there was no internet, and I lived too far out of town to get cable. So, in the early 90s when I transferred out of my 2 year college at home and went to a 4 year school, that was when Nirvana, the Seattle scene and Grunge came along….we both loved it. Because of the popularity of Nirvana, a lot of music that had been considered alternative/college rock, started to get more mainstream airplay, I had access to cable TV, and I started learning about that. When I met my wife in 1994, we were into pretty much the same modern music, we were both huge Nirvana fans, and I was just learning a lot of the stuff she’d been listening to. But whereas I had been following a hard rock/heavy metal path, she was follwoing the alternative path, so she was able to introduce me to some things like The The, Screaming Trees, Afghan Whigs, I introduced her to artists like Pantera and White Zombie. Our musical tastes have by and large stayed in synch with each other, she does at times tend to latch onto things I have very little interest in because they just lack any sort of punch to my ear…stuff like Coldplay or Fleet Foxes, but then there is plenty of met she might not care as much about like the Sword or Mastodon. There are very few things that one of us is way into that the other doesn’t care much about….she was a big Smashing Pumpkins fan, I found them to be very hit and miss (though they put on a great live show), and one of my favorite bands is a holdover from the glam era called Enuff Z’uff, who basically had a couple hit singles at the height of glam in ‘89, but were never really a glam band, but because that’s how they were marketed, they were written off by everyone when glam died…but 20 years and 16 albums later they are making for my money some of the best melodic hard rock since the Beatles (she thinks the singer sounds too nasally, which is funny because she likes Billy Corgan?) But yes, new things come out, if they slap one of us upside the head the probably do the same ot the other. We both immediately loved the White Stripes and pretty much everything Jack White has done. I guess the only place we really don’t synch up always is what phases we go through. For a while she would pretty much exclusively have the classic rock station on in her car, and I was of the opinion that I like classic rock, but I’d rather hear the alternative station and find new things. For a while she was really into the AOR station (kind of like lighter, more adult contemporary rock), and I was into having the hard rock station on. Now she pretty much exclusively listens to a public radio station which has no format and plays mostly college rock, whereas I either like to listen to my Zune or talk radio. But I’d say 95 times out of 100, if one of us likes it, we both like it…4 of the other 5 times are opportunities for us to introduce each other to something new, and that 1 time out of 100 we disagree.

Gudinge's avatar

Me and my girlfriend listen mostly to the same music but we can think the complete opposite of artist.s

LeotCol's avatar

Yes in some ways but no in other ways….I hate busted…she loves them

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther