Would you rather buy a Gildan or American Apparel tshirt at a concert?

I’m in the process of evaluating tshirts for merchandising purposes for a small stage show. I’m interested in printing and selling only quality products, but the question of price and durability keeps coming up.

I personally love American Apparel tshirts because they are soft and fit very well. I dislike the boxy look.

Gildan is quite popular as well, though not quite as form fitting. It is however slightly thicker and significantly less expensive to produce.

As a consumer, what would you rather buy at a show? A slightly heavier, more boxy tshirt that may be a bit more durable, or a well fitted, soft and luxurious tshirt that may be a bit more thin? I’d be selling them for the same price…