I made a promise, and deliver it I shall.
@Sampson Okay.. Now let me deal with each of your points bit by bit (finally it arrives!). Sorry that it’s so long, but I like to be detailed in my analysis. =)
Firstly, you say that Generation Y is lacking the brilliant aspect of itself. Well, it’s kinda hard to judge so quickly seeing as most of Gen Y hasn’t had the chance to show this brilliant aspect yet. You list Elvis as one of your examples of brilliance. How do you think the older people back in the 60s viewed such a thing where thousands upon thousands of girls would go screaming for one person, almost like idol worship (and even the Beatles [think Beatlemania]? For them, the Sexual Revolution was going on and destroying the “moral fabric of their society”. “Free love” where sex is a part of everyday life and can be between many people? What utter rubbish! I doubt that they thought that their younger generation was going to turn the world into a better place.
Secondly, you’re saying that most talented people aren’t being exposed because talented people aren’t pretty. Now, is that really true? To start with, aren’t all those pretty people who appear on the TV talented in their own ways (ie acting). Furthermore, some of the most followed people on the TV aren’t exactly pretty. Oprah Winfrey? She’s okay-ish, and she’s been having her very public struggles with weight. Eddie Murphy? He’s definitely not bad looking, but stunning? Jackie Chan, now don’t we all just love his kung fu, but is he really that pretty? You see, these people who have this huge exposure must have it for some reason, and it ain’t necessarily because they’re pretty and shallow. Also, you have many people who are really famous on other forms of media (like books) and not just because they’re pretty. J. K. Rowling is one of the best-selling authors of our times, and yet she relies not on looks but on talent. Now I know that you’ll say that these people aren’t born in Generation Y. You are correct. But guess what? They got where they are because of their life experiences, which the current Generation Y doesn’t have because they’re still in the schools or fresh in their careers. Can’t exactly contribute hugely to society when you’re only just starting out can you?
Thirdly, your link from this reason to your examples of having shows such as “The Hills” doesn’t really follow. These shows are popular because they’re entertainment. Why would I, as a working man, after a long day at work, want to go back home and watch a highly philosophical discussion on the applicability of Eastern Morals to the Javanese tribesmen? I want to watch something to “kill my brain”, metaphorically speaking because I just want to relax. If I want my highly mentally stimulating stuff, I can always find it on the net or on other channels (like the Discovery Channel). If you’re going to say that many children nowadays aren’t watching such educational stuff, well… did all the children in generations past stimulate their minds with knowledge, or were they too busy playing? Same applies here, just that it’s in a different form.
Fourth, you claim that the Gen Y culture is out to make money and therefore there aren’t any truly talented people. Really now? In order to really tackle this statement, what do you mean by ‘truly talented’? The ability to play the saxophone and swing along to the big band? The ability to think about the world around us and write papers on them? The ability to help the poor peoples of the world? Well… if that’s so, then I say to you that Gen Y is producing these people, in the music schools, in the universities and the many charities around the world? So what if Gen Y is producing consumers? Ever since the concept of money came into being, we’ve all been consumers and wanted to make money. Hey, lookie here, that’s since the dawn of man! Just that Gen Y is able to do it better because it’s got the mass media (which has, “ironically”, been developed by the previous generation).
Gen Y hasn’t been molded to fit a form. People have been, are and always will be a diverse lot. True, the mass media is arguably killing off some of that diversity (as is Westernisation, but that’s another debate), yet isn’t the mass media in itself, extremely diverse? And can’t the mass media be used to promote that diversity?
Humans have always been focused on appearances, whether it’s now or before. Your comment on Bulimia can also be applied to now-dead practices such as foot-binding in China, where if a woman wasn’t food-bound, she’d find herself very hard-pressed to get a husband.
This leads on to the last, and perhaps most important, point. Did the girls of Gen Y grow up thinking that they must get a husband or else they’d be a shame onto their family? I change what I said previously in this thread and believe that Gen Y has had it better off than any other generation before it. Much of Gen Y grew up in a society where skin colour mattered less (racism will always exist, but nobody can deny that racism in Gen Y was anywhere as bad as previous generations), where women knew their rights and could vote, where gay people could get more understanding, where medicine and science reached a stage where many previously incurable diseases could be protected against and where people can live up till their 80s (medieval life expectancy was, on average, up till the 40s [or even 30s] and many people have died in the ancient past due to things we’d consider trivial now [Death from Toothache, anyone? Some ancient Egyptian nobility got it]). Gen Y grew up in a world where you could keep in touch with loved ones halfway across the globe (and even see and talk to them) with a dial of the phone, or even better, the internet. Food is aplenty, more and more people are getting a basic education, and life in general is better than humans ever dreamed it could be previously. Sure, we now have our problems such as pollution, but then again, which generation didn’t have their own problems? And who’s to say that humans aren’t dealing with these new problems?
Perhaps before you start beating down Gen Y without letting it prove itself directly to you, try giving it a chance eh? Look back on Gen Y in a few decades or so before passing your judgment.
P.S. I find it interesting how people here are criticising current musical talents and saying that they’re rubbish and how it’s proof of how low-down humanity has gone. Everyone has their differing opinions on what genius is. Just because I think your definition is wrong doesn’t mean that that genius doesn’t exist