@Fyrius I will admit to using some emotional arguments, and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that in this case. You seem fixated on the “give up your life” comment, but I started the paragraph with ” It’s not about a somewhat shorter life versus a somewhat longer one, it’s about quality of life”. Quality of life, not dying tomorrow or a few year earlier. I also acknowledged that smoking was a “legitimate” decision, basically because I don’t see any way out of it, it’s legal, you can do it, fine. I will not discuss whether it is stupid either, but you cannot defend smoking on the basis of rationality. “Rational” can mean a lot of things, but the simplest one is “based on reason”. A decision to smoke is not based on reason, it is base more on emotion than any of my arguments. Let’s take a rational approach to decision making on smoking. We will analyze the pros and cons of the decision, and weigh which side is better. That sounds rational.
Cons:
Greater risk of:
lung cancer
heart disease
emphysema
impotence
a number of other cancers
etc.
It makes you smell bad
It stains your teeth and makes them ugly
it will give you particularly unattractive wrinkles in the long term
If you are an American, you just eliminated the majority of women from potential dating partners, unless you manage to quit
likely cost of cigarettes in a year: $1800
decreased lung capacity and cardiovascular fitness
you will almost certainly want to quit someday, which you will find difficult and possible expensive since you will be physically and mentally addicted
That’s off the top of my head, I’m sure a much more extensive list could be compiled.
Pros:
So, there you have it, a rational analysis of the decision to smoke. Seems that smoking does not measure up.
OK, you’re going to want to throw something in Pros, I know, so here you go:
Pros:
Helps you fit in or look cool. OK, but that’s not really rational, if a clique doesn’t like you, smoking won’t make them. If they do, not smoking won’t change that. The large population (in the U.S. at least) is made up of a vast majority of non-smokers, so they will only like you less for smoking, since you will smell and have ugly teeth. The effects of peer pressure are based purely on emotion and are in no way rational.
Feels good. The first cigarette is not a pleasant experience, it takes work to make you enjoy it. The buzz is more like feeling sick than any kind of pleasant high. It only feels good when you have become addicted, because not having it feels bad because you are addicted. If you ever manage to break the addiction, you will find you feel better every day than you ever did from smoking. So, feeling good does not play a role, because when you try it, it will not feel good. Rationally, you should believe your own experience here rather than assume that eventually it will feel good.
So if you still think smoking is rational, then we clearly don’t agree on what rational means.