@Zen – I’m curious what you think we as citizens of countries where it is legal for us to speak our minds should do to help citizens of countries where it is NOT legal. In America, we can say any stupid, untrue thing we want, even if it’s to deny the Holocaust, indeed allowing people to say crazy shit is the best way we often have of knowing who we need to keep an eye on. But as much as it would be nice if we could, we can’t apply US laws and US customs to foreign people and their leaders. And even if we could, Iran would just be scratching the surface. The planet is littered with countries where the citizens live under oppressive rule, indeed many people on the planet have it FAR worse than your average Iranian citizen, all things considered. No, people shouldn’t be killed for speaking their minds, but it happens all over the world, every day…even in America, do you really think there aren’t people in positions of power living among us this very day who have had people who dared speak against them killed?
Now sure, we’d like to think that because our leaders don’t have people killed (well we do have targeted assassinations carried out on Al Quaeda leaders from time to time, but that’s different if only because Al Quaeda has sworn itself an enemy of the state, which I’m sure is how Ahmadinejad sees people who protest his victory for what it’s worth), but by and large, that’s because the money and power structure in this country make these methods unnecessary. We are less than a century and a half removed from our own past history of wild west vigilante justice ourselves, a time when politicians would still meet untimely deaths if they went up against the wrong people. Hell, our political system in many cities was controlled by the mafia as recently as 75 years ago (some say there are cities in America where it still is), but OK, a President ordering the execution a person who disputes his victory…well, that isn’t really something we’d do in America. Of course, we don’t have to. Virtually every other country in the world ran front page headlines in 2000 when Bush’s cronies rigged the Presidential elections, but the majority of Americans never realized that Bush cheated and would argue with you about it to this day, because the powers that be had enough influence to be able to tell the media, “move along, show’s over, nothing left to see here,” but then threw them a bone of sensationalism by allowing them to focus on things like butterfly ballots and dimpled chads…giving little but lip service to why tens of thousands of Democrats had been turned away from voting in Florida, the state which a) gave Bush the election, b) was decided by a couple hundred votes, and c) happened to have Bush’s brother as the governor and his campaign chair as the Secretary of State. Our powerful in this country don’t NEED to stoop to something as inelegant as bloodshed, money sees to that.
But bottom line here, I don’t like someone who is batshit crazy at the helm of a country which targets our allies (and possibly us), which is looking to obtain nuclear weaponry, so I want the US to use whatever it has at its disposal as appropriate. And what tools do we have to deal with rogue nations and leaders? Well, there is diplomacy, which amounts to frank discussions…if they’re serious about moving up in the world they’ll engage, and if they’re hell bent on doing it their own way, then diplomacy fails. We have incentives and sanctions, aka carrots and sticks…if both sides can engage in a little give and take, we can strike a balance that works until Iran sees the error of its ways and a Democracy flourishes, the way it happened with every other formerly oppressive regime throughout human history. And if none of that works, we have war.
I say we can stand up and advocate taking a tough stance, using whatever diplomatic power and carrots and sticks we have to get them to stop killing people for speaking their minds, but that’s it. The US is not, and can not afford to be the police of the world. Maybe if we were willing to become one of the highest taxed nations on the planet, we could afford to undertake a global effort to wipe out tyranny, but right now, what am I, for example, an unemployed Accountant from St. Paul, Minnesota SUPPOSED to do about the leader of Iran, a country which has a LONG track record of appalling human rights abuses, silencing dissent about a stolen election via violent methods, when I was unable to do anything about a stolen election in my own country when the dissent was silenced by non violent means?