Social Question

davidk's avatar

What do you think is the most controversial bit of revisionist history?

Asked by davidk (1432points) October 13th, 2009

Unlike other fields of study, people seem to get all bent out of shape when new evidence leads historians to reinterpret events. Why do you think many people treat history as if it is a “closed case?” What revisionist history is the most controversial and why?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

12 Answers

Zen's avatar

Anything to do with the Palestinians.

eponymoushipster's avatar

The fact that Pepsi, was, in fact, the choice of a new generation.

dpworkin's avatar

Dick Cheney’s ongoing attempt to reposition the Bush presidency, and more importantly his vice-presidency as a crucial nation-saving act of beneficence rather than a dystopian journey into the land of Big Brother.

tinyfaery's avatar

The big fat lie that Reagan was a good president. He left the country with a huge deficit, low approval ratings, he ignored the AIDS crisis and wasted billions on Star Wars. Nancy Reagan and the Republican propoganda machine really turned history on it’s head.

Are we all that stupid and/or forgetful?

drdoombot's avatar

I agree with @tinyfaery.

Another one would be the genocide of the Native Americans by the US government. I knew nothing about this until college, through independent study, which is a goddamned shame.

dpworkin's avatar

Yes @tinyfaery gets a GA. Why that homophobic, lying, belligerent, demented piece of shit Reagan has any honor left in this country is beyond me.

jrpowell's avatar

What tinyfaery said..

Nader could have been President while the cold war ended.

kevbo's avatar

Most is difficult for me to judge, but the thesis of 1491 is pretty flipping eye opening and contrary to what probably 99% of us learn in American History and perhaps the histories of the Americas.

True or not, many widespread “conspiracy” beliefs also hit the high water mark, IMO, especially those that revolve around events that preceed the information age.

Dog's avatar

@kevbo Great link!

filmfann's avatar

Reagan causing the break-up of the Soviet Union.
I agree with tinyfairie. Reagan should have been impeached. He wasn’t the great American patriot the Right portray him to be.

mattbrowne's avatar

Just look at a history book in Saudi Arabian schools.

Dog's avatar

I don’t suppose that this counts but I found it fascinating that overnight Michael Jackson went from social outcast to revered saint.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.
Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther