Send to a Friend

Did I just think of a perpetual motion device?
I know we are told that the laws of physics do not allow perpetual motion devices, but isn’t a planet orbiting the sun a perpetual motion device? It can go on forever with out violating the laws of physics.
I though of two arguments to this:
They aren’t moving in relation to each other, so technically no motion is happening.
-Then throw in another planet, and there will be relative motion. Also non-relative motion is still motion.
No work is being done, so it doesn’t violate any laws
-Well perpetual motion doesn’t imply work, so then this is still a perpetual motion device. If this is the only argument then perpetual motion is simply a misnomer, and we should change it to perpetual work device.
Any thoughts by some legitimate physicists?
Using Fluther
or