General Question

troubleinharlem's avatar

Why is it important not to wake a sleepwalker?

Asked by troubleinharlem (7999points) November 16th, 2009 from iPhone

What could/would happen?
If so, why?
Could I send it to MythBusters?

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

7 Answers

oratio's avatar

The only peril would probably be that you might startle the person. If gently done, there shouldn’t be any danger. It seems to be no more than the usual urban myth, passed down generations.

faye's avatar

You should wake a sleepwalker so they don’t hurt themselves. they are asleep the same as if they were in bed, but they might be disoriented at first.

Blonderaven's avatar

We had a long discussion on this in acting class. Our teacher was too tired from sleepwalking to teach so we discussed sleepwalking instead. To answer your question my teacher says not to wake a sleepwalker because sleepwalking can be very disorienting and it’s just better to lead the walker safely to bed

FreeRadical's avatar

In my psychology class we discussed this, and according to the professor it’s not true that waking sleepwalkers is dangerous or harmful.

In fact, waking sleepwalkers might stop them from doing something horrible, like this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homicidal_somnambulism

So, although them might be puzzled or annoyed, waking them up is definitely not a bad idea, and might actually prevent them from doing something silly at the very least.

trumi's avatar

The Cabinet of Dr Caligari!

:)

sliceswiththings's avatar

As a sleepwalker, I agree that waking up mid-walk is very disorienting. If they’re going to do something dumb, by all means wake them up if you can’t convince them in their sleep to go back to bed or redirect them. Once in my sleep I thought I had to feed my neighbors cats, so I left my house and almost broke into their house (they were all home and asleep). Luckily there was enough weird stuff that woke me up.

Basically it’s very disorienting, cause you make a different situation out of reality. For me, I always remember my episodes, if I wake up during them or not, so I’m always semi-conscious.

Janka's avatar

It is my understanding that the idea that waking up sleepwalkers is somehow dangerous is not true. It is pleasanter to the sleepwalker, as already pointed out, if you can just guide them back to bed without forcing them to wake up, but if you can’t, just wake them up before they hurt themselves.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther