Jay Smooth is the man you want to go to for this. He gives a voice to Hip Hop that is both logical and eloquent, something you don’t often find on the internet.
Rapping is music, and it’s part of Hip Hop music, but Hip Hop is a culture. Where that gets mixed up is the stuff on the radio that’s ⅓ R&B, ⅓ Pop, and ⅓ Rap. I call that Hip Hop, but only for lack of a better word.
Hip Hop music contains a lot of different elements including rapping, DJing, MCing, sampling, and so on. That’s why it get’s confusing :)
Eminem is not the greatest rapper, although his style is (or more like was) very well developed. Rap is not just “noise” or “swear words” or “lame club music.” Please listen to some better music than what is on the radio before making up these broad generalizations. It’d be really easy (and stupid) to say that jazz is just pointless notes made up as you go along, and symphony music is just 300 year old Pop.
My Personal List of the Best Rappers:
2Pac, Notorious B.I.G., MF DOOM, Jay-Z, Lil’ Wayne, Aesop Rock, and select members of the Wu Tang Clan. These are rappers, so please don’t say otherwise. It’s what they do. Common is wonderful, but his music is better than his rapping so I put him in a different category.
The only real debate is if you have a musical artist, or song, that is melodic, produced, and includes rapping but is more of a pop song, what do you call this? Probably Hip Hop. But it’s difficult to say.
This is a really good topic of conversation to discuss and not inform. Telling people that an entire genre of music is garbage is a pretty lame way to have a conversation. Especially if you don’t even take the time to spell check.
@Steve_A The Beastie Boys are Hip Hop, and they do rap in their music, but it’s more of a hodgepodge. They actually started out as a punk band! I’m just not going to comment on Kid Rock… Ugh…
Please keep up the lively debate, but try to keep an open mind! Thanks all.