I’ve had both, and I favor the PS3.
Not that there’s anything wrong with the 360 while it works. But they stop working, rather frequently. The following is an off hand list of people I know who have owned an x box that it stopped working and had to be repaired/replaced.
-My brother, twice
-My room mate, twice
-Myself, twice.
-My friends broke, but still “kind of” worked (drive issues)
-My uncle
-Another friends was breaking prior to it being stolen.
-My brothers friend
-Another friend of mine
Honestly, that’s most of the people I know who have one (and some who I didn’t even know had them). 3rd parties estimated that something like 80% of launch edition 360’s failed within the first year, and something like 35% of currently made ones still fail. They have MAJOR issues with over heating because Microsoft found out its cheaper to use crappy welding material that will literally “un-weld” when the system gets too hot, and just replace the ones that people complain about (That’s actually what causes the red rings… they still use that material, just not in the same place anymore).
Furthermore I had my xbox stolen and I immediately called and canceled my live account since I knew I wouldn’t eb able to afford another 360. 6 months later I noticed that they never canceled my account because somewhere in the 45 minute call to Banglepor or wherever in India they’ve outsourced their call center too… they simply “forgot” to cancel it whilst trying to wrap their heads aroudn the concept that it was stolen.
I had to call and waste another hour of my time telling them I had canceled it 6 months prior and they didn’t believe me until I finally said, and I quote… “Listen you dumb bitch, get on xbox live, type in my account name, and you’ll see that my last login was over 6 months ago….. IT WAS STOLEN AND I CALLED YOU GUYS YOU HAVE THE CALL ON RECORD, WHY THE HELL ELSE WOULD I CALL???” ..... They finally refunded me my money.
WHEN it was working, the 360 was just as fun as my PS3, and it has a slightly larger library (it used to have a massively larger library of games, but the PS3 has caught up considerably). The graphics are better on the PS3, but not by THAT much.
I would take the PS3 just so you don’t have to deal with Microsofts shoddy worksmanship and crappy customer service.