For me, story lines are what used to count, and sometimes still do.
I first started playing RPG’s because I loved how there was a whole story that you were living, with defined characters who’s personalities grow as you play, as opposed to it just being an excuse to support gameplay.
The older Final Fantasy titles, Chrono Trigger, Breath of Fire II or Earthbound are some good examples, among many others. It was fascinating.
That said, I’ve played way too many role playing games in the past plus ten years, and while the formula usually defines it, I tire of prepubescent kids destined to save existence from some ancient god when they aren’t even the age to have sex yet. I’m sick and tired of amnesic farming village boys wearing goggles that never find any use in the game, and I’m tired of archetypal bag guys with flowing hair and trenchcoats.
And I’m not a particular fan of the anime design most of these games have, either.
Not saying it’s no good, that’s what RPG fans enjoy and if it works why change it, but it is reheated material, so today it takes something original to impress me. (Koudelka, Shadow Hearts, the Shin Megami series.)
I’ve turned my interest towards survival horror, because first off I’m a huge fan of anything horror related, and they often have great and elaborate stories. Besides fear factor and atmosphere, this is what survival horror relies on to define itself.
Even if it’s a failed and laughable attempt, (Night Trap lol.) I can usually forgive crap control and shoddy gameplay elements in lieux of a good story. (Silent Hill being one of my fave series. Anyone who played those will know that Konami knows how to weave a tale, and fuck you up while they’re at it.)
But I’m not in it just to have a bedtime story. I still play washed up JRPG’s because I love the gameplay and exploiting whatever technicalities I may find, and if not, I love treasure hunting. My main goal in most games these days is to collect every single item that the game has, even stuff I know I’ll never use. It’s like a fun challenge for me.
Which means I also love all the post Symphony of the Night Castlevania games (Including Symphony as my all time favourite video game ever.) where there’s always tons of cool shit to find.
That and they,re all pretty and Goth.
But I play most of anything…the exception is racing, wrestling and sports game.
I also love tactical RPG’s, (FF tactics, Kartia, Hoshigami, Stella Deus.) because of the immersion factor, as well as the over the top grandiose religious themed plots. And politics. epic.
I’m not adverse to fighting games either, street Fighter Alpha 3 and the Soul Calibur series being immense fun for me.
I’m not sure if my reasons and attraction to games is much different than anyone though, aside from perhaps a few bouts of being picky.