Umm, @ucme, did you ever consider how people who are left out might feel? Obviously not. I don’t care about your intent. I care about the impact questions like this have on the community. If it’s a question that calls for inequality—placing one jelly above all the others, or even several jellies above the others, it is, in my opinion, a destructive, mean-spirited question, no matter what your intent.
This question calls for judgments about others. As such, it is subject to popularity issues, issues of what people know about, and things of that nature. It appeals to the cliquish nature of people who have their own little hobby horses to ride.
This is no way to bring out the best in people. I mean look at some of the top questions—one is unintentionally a laughingstock, and the other is a celebration of a marriage. Is this how we want to be known? Really? A place full of cliques and teasers? Did a one of these questions appeal to the intellect? Did any of them seem particularly thoughtful? I dunno, I haven’t gone back to look at them, so I suppose there might be some, but there are far too many ones chosen purely for insider entertainment value. I don’t that that’s any way to advertise a website that prides itself on being inclusive and intellectual.
But even if there were questions that I thought were representative of the flavor of fluther, it would be bullshit. We all have different opinions. The only opinions that count, however, are those of the people who propose questions. Of course the popular questions will be put forth. They’re the ones people know about. But do they really promote fluther? Obviously, I don’t think so.
All I’m saying, and I’ve been warning about this a number of times, so perhaps people are thinking “there he goes again,” is that this is the edge of a slippery slope. People already think there are cliques and such. This kind of thing only makes it worse, by excluding people who don’t know the references or people who don’t belong to the popular groups. Which, I fear, are beginning to conglomerate.
Perhaps this place has outgrown me. There are some places I cannot follow.