Why were the constitutional amendments amendments? Why weren't they written into the original document?
Asked by
lilikoi (
10110)
March 3rd, 2010
Observing members:
0
Composing members:
0
14 Answers
They were unsure that they wouldn’t need to change it again soon.
They had a revolution to finish and a large part of the British army breathing down their necks and figured the nitty gritty details could wait a bit.
The amendments are added separately to keep the original document in tact as it was written at the time. This is the same reason why new amendments have to be added to cancel out old amendments… to keep people from forgetting what the document once said.
the amendments were written to satisfy New York, which wanted them in the original document. Other founders didn’t want them in the original body.
You mean the Bill of Rights, or every amendment?
One reason is because there’s no shortage of idiots that believe they know what’s best for us. Temperance movement forcing prohibition for example.
Fortunately, at least for now, the amendments can show for all time that we realized we fucked up (prohibitions repeal) so hopefully, maybe enough of us will have learned a lesson from history and fight to keep it from being repeated.
the original 12 amendments, aka the Bill of Rights.
The British army was not a factor. The Revolutionary War was essentially over in 1781, the Constitution was written in 1787. The Bill of Rights was added later.
The Constitution was ratified and went into effect in early 1789. There had been pressure from the beginning to add articles to the Constitution that promoted individual liberty and limited government power. The original document did not have a “Bill of Rights-some of the Founders and Framers, like Alexander Hamilton, did not think that they were needed. To avoid a second Constitutional convention, that might have undone all of the debate and compromises that went into the original document, the articles were added as amendments starting in late 1789. It is interesting to read some of the proposed articles that did not “make the cut” during the debates that produced the first ten ammendments.
To have it ratified in haste the first ten admendments aka “The Bill of Rights” it was agreed would be put in as admendments. There admendments were always an option, The laws in the Bill of Rights could not be ratified or agreed upon enough to put them in the body, so it was a sort of compromise to add them as the first admendments. That is how I remember it.
It’s hard to think of everything.
Answer this question
This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.