General Question

prolificus's avatar

For those who are transgender, or a variation thereof... (details inside)?

Asked by prolificus (6583points) April 30th, 2010

I’m looking for first-hand experiences only, please. Feel free to answer any one or all:

1. How old were you when you made the decision to transition (or at least to identity as T)?

2. If you have chosen not to undergo any medical procedures to change your appearance and/or genitalia, and your appearance is significantly different from your identity (e.g. you’re MTF and you have kept your penis, or you’re FTM and you have sizeable breasts), how do you affirm your identity as trans?

3. What were the factors that made you decide to acknowledge to yourself and to others that you are transgender (or a variation thereof)?

4. Do your parents know? If so, how did you tell them and how did they react?

5. This is similar to question #2, but slightly different: If it is not obvious by your outward appearance that you are the gender by which you identify as, do you make it a point to identify your gender (or whatever) to those with whom you intact on a regular basis?

Actually, I have a lot more questions, but this is it for now. I’m asking because I’m questioning my own gender identity.

Observing members: 0 Composing members: 0

21 Answers

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

I began identifying as a gender non-conforming person about 2 years ago, have made no physical changes (as I don’t have a problem with my body, just with what others expect of me because I have it) and I affirm my identity around people that I care about and through my LGBT activism and work within the community. The factors were knowing many trans people in college and learning about genderfluid identities through the LGBT office at NYU and learning queer theory. My father is dead and he never even knew I wasn’t straight, let alone that I don’t feel like a woman. My mother ignores both statements when I make them and says that when I was an infant, I put pearls on my neck and stopped crying which means, clearly, I’m a real girl. Most of the time I pass as a woman but my friends know how I identify and when I get close enough to a new friend, I tell them as well. Again, I know we disagreed in the past, but if you need ANY help on this, I am there for you about any of this and can connect you to people who did transition or who present differently, etc. Oh and incidentally, I just stumbled on this great op-ed by a trans individual.

Response moderated
Response moderated
Response moderated
loser's avatar

1. I transitioned at the age of 35.

2. I went with top-op only. I couldn’t pass with what I had.

3. To most people I’m a guy now. It was only during the transitioning process that I really told people about being transgendered.

4. I told my parents the day before my surgery. They freaked out. (And STILL use the wrong pronouns!)

5. Testosterone really helped. I wear a beard and people don’t seem to think twice about me.

Dog's avatar

[Mod Says:] Please respect the asking party and take side conversations to PM. Thanks!

MissAnthrope's avatar

@prolificus – I’m sensitive to your wanting first-hand experiences of transgender folk, so I’m wondering if you are interested in hearing from genderqueer people?

gemiwing's avatar

@prolificus – I have the same question as @MissAnthrope . I don’t want to answer your question with something that isn’t what you’re looking for.

prolificus's avatar

@MissAnthrope and @gemiwing – Of course! That’s why I said (any variation thereof). <smiles>

gemiwing's avatar

@prolificus okay :)

I don’t know what to call what I am. I think I exist in the gray area. I don’t think of myself as female or male most of the time. Sometimes I feel, and refer to myself, as female- other times I am as far away as it gets. I don’t identify as trans- I’m still figuring out all of it and where I fit in. I tend to think of myself as Queer – in the broadest sense/gender/sexuality. It’s all one for me. I’m not looking to transition so perhaps my answers won’t help you, yet if you would indulge me and allow me to get them out. A bit of therapy if you will.

I’ve decided not to transition because there is nothing for me to transition to. There is no gender-free area for me. Plus, I have a deep rooted belief that part of my personal experience, this time around, is to learn to love myself and to find my peace despite my body. (this is not only about gender, but about health/mental issues as well.)

I affirm my identity in that space that allows us to know we are without sight, touch, smell, taste or sound. I’m trying to live beyond my body, as it were. I don’t think this is a “noble” thing- it’s just what I personally feel I need to do.

I had to acknowledge my feelings because they were standing in the way of so much self-love and love of others. I was cheating myself by not loving myself.

I still identify as a female, in public- not because I’m ashamed or anything. It’s just easier for me to float along with it. It’s something I’m looking at myself long and hard about. What does it mean that I’m okay to let this slide sometimes? Why does it drive me to speak out at other times? I’m still not sure.

I don’t talk to my parents about it- in a way I view it as none of their business. This is private to me and I realize how fortunate I am that I don’t feel that disparity between outside/inside and all the judgement that comes from it. Hubbs knows and I know him- that’s good enough for me. We have no guy/girl split in the house chores/expectations/communications.

prolificus's avatar

(I’m here… I’m thinking. Thank you for your responses.)

Edit: I do have thoughts and questions regarding everyone’s answers thus far. I need time to ponder. I suppose waiting until the end of a hectic work-week and having a fried brain is not the time to ask a serious question(s) such as this. But, I do have lots of lurve for all. Thank you .

gemiwing's avatar

@prolificus I think taking time to ponder is just right, in this case

KatawaGrey's avatar

I am not genderqueer nor am I transgendered but I just want to say that I look forward to reading these answers and also I wanted to ask @loser what “top-op” means.

augustlan's avatar

@KatawaGrey If I can presume to answer for @loser, he was a female-to-male transition. I’m assuming “top-op” means breast removal only, leaving the vagina intact.

KatawaGrey's avatar

@augustlan: I thought so, but I wasn’t sure if there may have been another meaning of which I was unaware.

MacBean's avatar

@KatawaGrey: @augustlan got it! Thumbs up!

@prolificus, I’m planning on giving you a detailed answer to this question, either here or by PM. It’s just taking some time to compile it because I don’t talk about this in detail a whole lot.

MissAnthrope's avatar

@prolificus – Okay, I just wanted to ask before I chimed in, in case it wasn’t what you were looking for. :)

I was a pretty normal little girl, I liked dolls, could play with my dollhouse for hours, loved my tea set, that sort of typical girl stuff. But at some point in my childhood, my maleness began to assert itself. I remember one Easter when I was about 7 or 8, screaming my head off as my mom chased me around with this horrendous frilly dress/gloves/hat/socks/shoes outfit. I so did not want to put it on, I even ran out the door of our apartment around the building trying to escape her. Eventually, I lost, of course. I wish I had the picture she took after she wrangled it on me, my face really just says it all.

I then was a tomboy. I still played with Barbies, but I also liked skateboarding, climbing trees, sword fighting, GI Joes, and playing with boys. I never really grew out of the tomboyishness, and that’s an easy way to classify me now, because I definitely have both male and female sides and I don’t much identify with one over the other. I haven’t worn a dress since I was 20.. I don’t know if you’ve ever watched The L Word, but there’s an epidsode where Carmen’s family basically forces Shane to wear a dress. It’s supposed to be funny, but I did not find it funny, I felt so totally sorry for Shane. Shane in that dress is how I feel in dresses.. it’s like putting a guy in a dress. It just looks ridiculous on me and I feel ridiculous.

As I’ve explored my sexuality and gender over the years, for a while I felt exactly half girl, half boy. I felt a definite line there. Now, I feel like the boy side dominates. I realize that my brain is definitely wired more male than female. In relationships, I am pretty much the guy in terms of roles, and I like it that way. I dated one butch woman who was more male than I was, and it was kind of disconcerting. I liked it in a sense, but I was so unused to it that I didn’t quite know what to do.

I’m way more comfortable in men’s clothes. I have a weird body shape, more male than female (excepting the female equipment); no hips, no ass, no kidding. I can pull my pants off without unbuttoning them. Women’s clothes feel really weird to me and they are not meant for people built like men. So, I know the men’s clothes aren’t flattering, but they’re comfortable and they suit me.

I’ve considered gender re-assignment, but have come to the conclusion that it’s not for me. I’ve kind of gotten used to “me” as I am, even though it’s probably weird to a lot of people. I know I don’t fit into normal gender roles. It’s even difficult in the lesbian world, because most lesbians break off and identify as butch or femme. I feel left out quite a bit, it’s difficult to find someone not interested in rigid types like that. I mean, I’m butch and femme. I kinda like it. I feel like it makes me well-rounded.

I don’t feel so out of sync with my body that I feel I need to change it. Like I said, I’ve considered it. I kind of would like a penis, if we’re being totally honest here. But I also like having a vagina.. and weighing the post-surgery penis and that it’s not quite as functional as a natural one, I think I’m okay with what I’ve got. It works, it’s fun, girls like it.. and I’m pretty okay with that.

Edit: I was thinking about what I said and I don’t have any issues identifying as a woman, because I really like women. In fact, I don’t like to say it out loud much for fear of offending people, but I don’t much like men as a generality. I kind of don’t know what women see in them. :P I’m not a man-hater, exactly. I do have male friends that I care for quite a bit, but it’s really like separating the wheat from the chaff. What I find lacking in men, I find in abundance in women. So it’s not difficult for me to call myself female or identify as a woman. I feel like I’m in really good company. (and I hope I said that in a way that is understandable and doesn’t piss people off)

Simone_De_Beauvoir's avatar

@MissAnthrope I’m butch and femme. I kinda like it. I feel like it makes me well-rounded. – yes! That! I know that!

laureth's avatar

I understand that “I’m butch and femme” thing too. And like @MissAnthrope, I’ve never found it necessary to change my body because there’s nothing I could change it to that would be any better than what I’m changing it from.

This is the way I describe it: my biological father was a guy, so that makes me half-guy.

downtide's avatar

ooh how did I miss this one?

1. How old were you when you made the decision to transition (or at least to identity as T)?
About age 30 (13 years ago), although at that time I made the decision not to act on it at the time because my daughter was young and I wanted to wait until she was 18. At that point I started identifying more openly as transgendered (FTM)

2. If you have chosen not to undergo any medical procedures to change your appearance and/or genitalia, and your appearance is significantly different from your identity (e.g. you’re MTF and you have kept your penis, or you’re FTM and you have sizeable breasts), how do you affirm your identity as trans?
I have not yet begun physical transition (though I have now started on the long slow NHS path towards it). So currently I have had no surgical or hormone treatment, although I already pass fairly well. I’m blessed with a naturally androgynous body and I present totally as male.

3. What were the factors that made you decide to acknowledge to yourself and to others that you are transgender (or a variation thereof)?
Being desperately unhappy with trying to force myself into a role that didn’t fit. I’ve always known that I’m male in all ways except biological, and trying to force myself to fake femininity ended up making me seriously depressed. Most of the depression ended when I stopped trying to fake it, and just started living the way I always felt I was.

4. Do your parents know? If so, how did you tell them and how did they react?
I haven’t openly told them yet but I would be surprised if they hadn’t noticed. Although I haven’t lived with them for 25 years and I only see them a few times a year.

5. This is similar to question #2, but slightly different: If it is not obvious by your outward appearance that you are the gender by which you identify as, do you make it a point to identify your gender (or whatever) to those with whom you intact on a regular basis?
I have told most of my friends, and most of them now refer to me by my male name and use male pronouns. I’m still not officially out at work or with the extended family (parents, uncles/aunts etc) but again, based on my current physical appearance I’m sure people have guessed or suspect even if they’re too polite to mention it. Coming out at work is next on the agenda – I need to do that in the next few months before I can change my name legally. After that I’ll be out pretty much everywhere.

bookish1's avatar

Hi @prolificus:

Hope I’m not jumping in too late to be helpful to you or others.

1. How old were you when you made the decision to transition (or at least to identity as T)?
I was 22 when I came out and also decided to transition medically and socially. I am “FTM” according to the medical language but I am not binary. PM if you’d like to hear more about this.

2. If you have chosen not to undergo any medical procedures to change your appearance and/or genitalia, and your appearance is significantly different from your identity (e.g. you’re MTF and you have kept your penis, or you’re FTM and you have sizeable breasts), how do you affirm your identity as trans?
I have been on hormones for more than a year now, and I am saving up for top surgery. I am read properly as male more than 50% of the time now, for which I am very grateful, but before the hormones started to change my face and my voice, I was very nervous in social situations, especially with new people. I would either try to correct people when they misgendered me (easier said than done sometimes!), or tell people ahead of time (by email or facebook PMs, often) if we were going to be having extended interactions.

Non-binary people who are not taking hormones or seeking other medical forms of transition can still bind or wear breastforms, pack or tuck, wear makeup, etc. I have seen trans people do all of these things. Just ideas.

3. What were the factors that made you decide to acknowledge to yourself and to others that you are transgender (or a variation thereof)?
Well an immediate factor was dating a trans person going in the opposite direction (not binary either, but roughly ‘MTF’). Before I met her, I did not even realize that the kind of change I had been hoping for (i.e., taking pharmaceutically produced testosterone) was possible. More indirect factors were just realizing that the way things were going, I could not ever conceive of not being depressed, and I could not envision myself ever “growing up,” because I was not a woman and did not know how to be one. After coming out and especially starting hormones (and I had a significant wait between these two steps), I am happier than I knew it was possible to be.

4. Do your parents know? If so, how did you tell them and how did they react?
Yes. Badly. Sticking heads in sand, calling me a pervert and suggesting “restorative therapy” (electro shock torture for those ‘afflicted with gender confusion’!) I had stockholm syndrome for a LONG time. Cared about my family and disappointing them, even though they had been abusive to me my whole life. It took a whole lot of being (figuratively) beaten over the head by a previous partner for me to realize that I had to make the choice to transition for myself, and that doing this was not being selfish. It was allowing me to be a better and happier person.

5. This is similar to question #2, but slightly different: If it is not obvious by your outward appearance that you are the gender by which you identify as, do you make it a point to identify your gender (or whatever) to those with whom you intact on a regular basis?
N/A for me. I am read pretty consistently as male now, which is what I want, given that our cissexist world currently only has room for men/male and women/female.

If anyone reading this would like to PM me with respectful questions, please feel free to do so and I’ll answer as best as I am able.

Answer this question

Login

or

Join

to answer.

This question is in the General Section. Responses must be helpful and on-topic.

Your answer will be saved while you login or join.

Have a question? Ask Fluther!

What do you know more about?
or
Knowledge Networking @ Fluther