OK, time for me to chime in a little bit. I’ve thought about all of the things people have brought up and here’s some thoughts that led me to ask the question in the first place.
1) In my lifetime, even though the left has been “business-friendly”, the right has always been far friendlier.
2) One of the core “principles” of the right is self-reliance, and by that I mean that those on the right are far more likely to look at the world and say “making it is MY sole responsibility,” and thus they are more likely to be the ones who would take an entrepreneurial approach to life and start their own business….not to say that liberals don’t own businesses, plenty do, I just think the core mindset of conservatism makes people more likely to be willing to assume the level of risk required to reject the security of a regular job and take the risks to truly succeed or fail 100% on their own terms.
3) It has been my observation that business interests, though they always play both sides, tend to give more money to right leaning politicians than to left.
4) Ergo, it stands to reason that the majority of places where I spend my money are owned by people with whom I would have severe political disagreements.
So, I assume that were I to question the political views of the owners of every business at which I spend my money, there might well be a number of my “favorite” places where I would have a moral concern about frequenting.
Now clearly, when I ask myself what makes this different, it’s not simply that I “know” what the owner’s politics are, it’s that he so flagrantly exhibits his politics out in the open. Yet, why should that bother me? If I go into a business that has a great deal of liberal propaganda on display, I feel like this is my kind of people, my kind of business, a place I’m happy to frequent.
So at issue for me is, I believe you should keep controversial issues like politics and religion outside of your business, I certainly would do so if I ran a business, because I wouldn’t want anyone to feel unwelcome. But if anything, when I see political or religious rhetoric with which I agree in a place of business, I feel somehow more OK with that. And this makes me wonder how hypocritical I’m being here.
Then I consider that even though it would not be MY choice to put my political views on display were I to run a business, I do believe strongly in free speech, I believe it’s the business owner’s right to tell me verbally, in print or in any other manner what he believes, it’s his right to believe what he believes and to express that belief, and whether I like it is not a concern. I am against censorship in any form, even if I would rather not be subjected to the thing that would be censored. Censorship is not for me an issue of taste, it’s an issue of choice, I believe people should have the choice in what they choose to consider or not consider, but they should not have the choice as to the availability of points of view. All things should be out there for the taking, and nothing should be forced upon someone.
So, is this thrusting his views upon me? Well, I know when I go in there if there is something new posted on the wall, I’m going to find it politically ignorant, sophomoric and wrong headed, so really the choice is mine whether to read it or not. So again, where is the problem? Is it the lack of equal time? Should the owner also post anti-right rhetoric in the interest of equal time? Well, he’s a private citizen, he owns his business, it’s his choice what to post. There’s no law, nor should there be, saying that he has to remain neutral when dealing with the public. Yes, in my mind it’s good business, but it would be good business for the hippie coffee shops to take down the “legalize it” bumper stickers off the wall as well.
So I look at why I shop at ANY business. Basically, it’s a matter of self-interest…I want to purchase products and services that meet my needs (or desires more accurately) at prices I can afford to pay (or choose to pay more accurately). That’s it. This pizza meets a particular need/want for me, and the price is very fair in my estimation for what is delivered. It is a simple business transaction, and exchange of something I want (a great pizza) for something the business wants (money).
Ultimately though, I realize it’s my money, I can choose to spend it however I want and can refuse my business to anyone I don’t feel like giving my business to for whatever reason. For example, about 10 miles or so from my house, there is an appliance store which ALWAYS has some extremely religious proselytizing on its sign facing the highway…I’ve never set foot in the store, and I have no desire to do so. But of course there are several appliance stores with great prices and service far closer to me, so do I not give them my business because I really feel uncomfortable with a business trying to tell me how to live my life? (I do feel that.) Or do I not give them my business because it would be out of the way and inconvenient to do so?
Same with real estate agents who have the Jesus fish in their ads. Well, I would never call that guy, but I have a lot of choices, and if I ever need an agent, I’d go with the person who found us our house. So even though I find it distasteful that he mixes his religious views with business, that’s not the reason I’ve never called him. I went into a pawn shop once that had Fox News on the TV and Rush Limbaugh on the radio. I didn’t buy anything because I didn’t find anything to buy. I’ve never gone back, but I’m rarely in the area where that pawn shop is, and I just wasn’t impressed with their selection enough to make a special trip when there are nicer shops closer to my house. I remember all these things, these affronts to my sensibilities, I think of them as additional reasons not to give them my business, but I can’t honestly tell myself that I’d have given ANY of these people my business if they’d kept their views hidden.
So, I get down to it and I think, well, I get the product I want for a price I’m happy to pay, I am not rewarding the owner’s idiocy, I am rewarding his job well done (even if I don’t like his politics, OR his personality, he still makes a quality product and he earns the money I pay for it), he is not doing anything that is illegal or wrong, I am not forced to absorb his rantings (I choose to look at them KNOWING they will irritate me), I don’t feel he has no “right” to his opinions, the way he expresses him or anything else, and I have no idea if the second best pizza shop might be owned by someone twice as bad in my estimation.
Furthermore, to those who said it’s about all the small pebbles, I gotta tell you, I live in Minnesota, the only state that didn’t vote for Reagan in ‘84, we’re unabashedly liberal compared to a lot of the rest of the country (we may not be California or New York, but you know we’re going to be blue in the Presidential column time and again). The owner makes his views hard to ignore, and yet, I simply can’t imagine that a good share of his customers, probably more than half, are liberal and choose to ignore this aspect. I really can’t imagine any business being that busy if liberals in Minnesota refused to go there.
In other words, I don’t think there’s any way to wake people up to this, I think he’s made his views self evident, and I think most liberals have decided you take the good, you take the bad. And were I to stop going there, mount a viral campaign to boycott the restaurant, and write him a letter explaining how he lost my business of 16 years, I’m just thinking if his political views are important enough to him that he would risk offending patrons by putting them up, he not only expects, but accepts there is going to be some hate mail. I’d have a very hard time believing I’d be the only one to take this step, and I fail to see how it could do any good.
So, I get down to the nitty gritty and I ask myself, am I cutting off my nose to spite my face if I just stop going here. Let’s say I spend $150—$200 a year in carry out from this place, I’ve seen them pull that much in while I’ve been waiting for my pizza on a busy Saturday night.
In short, is a protest which has no purpose (what are my demands, after all, if I believe he has the right to express his views in a place he owns just as I have a right to ignore it) a protest worth mounting, when I would be the only one to bear a significant loss of something I enjoy. Is my concern really that the money is going to someone who might use it for purposes I wouldn’t approve of, when I know damn well that a good share of the money I spend goes for purposes I wouldn’t approve of (like my mortgage at Bank of America, I’m sure they have my best interests at heart, right?). And knowing that if he were displaying left wing rhetoric instead, I’d be more likely to think of it as my kind of place, am I not being a tad too hypocritical in even considering a one person (or more) boycott for doing something I believe is his full right to do anyway? If he’s doing nothing that I see as technically “wrong” and he is providing me with a quality product at a fair price, what moral high ground do I have to stand on in deciding to not frequent this place?
It would be one thing if I were not treated well or if I felt in some way unsafe in this place. I don’t fear that my car is going to be vandalized in the parking lot because it has Obama stickers on it, I don’t think I will ever be refused service or even spoken to rudely or even in an unfriendly manner by any of the employees, I don’t feel they will ever cheat me in any way, and it’s not as if the wait staff discusses politics with me….in fact, the only thing that “offends” not even me, but my sensibilities is something that I can choose to read or not read, which when I read I know full well before I even read it that my sensibilities will be offended. Nothing I do will change this person’s mind, nor will it change his way of conducting his business, and his decades long history of providing the best pizza there is at reasonable prices is going to hold far more weight than if the owner (who is never seen in the restaurant) is a grade A asshole.
So, by not going there, I have concerns about potentially being hypocritical and out of sync with my own value system. But by going there, I wonder if I’m being MORE hypocritical in choosing my own personal pleasure over my deeply held beliefs. Am I, if even in an immaterial way, supporting propaganda which is antithetical to my own beliefs, simply to enjoy a guilty pleasure? To what do I owe the greater moral responsibility, my adherence to my own set of values which says that all are entitled to the free expression of their opinions, or to my belief that if I in any way undermine my own values, I am complicit in their destruction? Yet in the pursuit of moral purity, when I know that the only difference between this business and many others is simply that I know that the politics of the owner are antithetical to my own. Does making a step like this morally obligate me to research the political views of all businesses which I frequent, or is ignorance a valid excuse? Is it a matter of the level or type of rhetoric (the type which your stupid, probably racist relative chooses to email you all the time even though they know you voted for Obama), is it a matter of the flaunting the views in what preferably would be a neutral environment? It seems that all potential paths are fraught with some degree of moral peril, as are all decisions one can make in life. How can I purely make the decision based not on what I “want” but one what is the most morally correct and least hypocritical/self-contradictory/self-defeating overall?
I guess I’m really kind of surprised at how almost unanimous it was that people said they would give up the pizza and not go there, and I guess what I’m looking for is a clear moral barometer to say that x is the path that most clearly reflects ALL of my values (not just my political beliefs) and is fraught with the least amount of moral difficulty.
I guess I’ll pose this to everyone who said they would not go here anymore. Would you ALSO refuse your business to an organization which proselytized its beliefs, if you AGREED with their beliefs? And if not, what makes it acceptable, not hypocritical, and in line with your total system of values to behave in this inconsistent manner?