Look at these differences in speech, and convention, a century has done... do you have other examples?
Asked by
zenele (
8260)
May 27th, 2010
Phileas Fogg was not known to have either wife or children, which may
happen to the most honest people; either relatives or near friends,
which is certainly more unusual. He lived alone in his house in
Saville Row, whither none penetrated. A single domestic sufficed to
serve him.
From Around the world in 80 days, of course.
Nowadays, I think it would offend half the fluther population, and insult the other half.
Observing members:
0
Composing members:
0
8 Answers
I think it would offend…
What would? The writing style?
I don’t think it’s offensive, just a little old-fashioned. What do you suppose folks would find offensive about it?
“not known to have either wife or children, which may
happen to the most honest people;”
“A single domestic sufficed to
serve him.”
Maybe I’m old-fashioned.
But I got my two babes to write in my Q. Yay.
* sigh *
Well, sure writing styles and moral conventions have changed in 100 years but isn’t that why we like to read classics? Although, having said that, there has been a great deal of censorship of Huckleberry Finn in recent years because of its condescension to Jim. I don’t believe in censoring fiction from the past; I do believe in using it as departure points for discussion.
(And now a third “babe” has weighed in.)
I see nothing offensive or insulting here, especially to those experienced with 19th century English literature. Many of us are literate and openminded enough to deal with a wide range of moral approaches.
Those among us who are unlikely to even approach such literature are certainly sheltered form offense or insult. I pity them more than I fear for their sensibilities.
@zenele Ain’t you the sneaky ol’ dog?
I agree with all above, no offense.
Maybe a longing among the more reclusive for affordable domestics. LOL
How about changes in the meanings of words, such as “gay” (which was once and is now primarily defined as “1 a: happily excited : merry [in a gay mood]; b: keenly alive and exuberant; having or inducing high spirits [a bird’s gay spring song]; 2 a: bright, lively [gay sunny meadows”]; b: brilliant in color; etc.) or “diva” (“a principal female singer in an opera or concert organization”)?
Answer this question