@anartist Uh, no. I completely ignored her bringing up the camps and ovens where my and millions of families lost our loved ones. I won’t give the anti-semites the pleasure of a figure, but lets say 10% of my family survived. (I can hear the drooling).
It was specifically that one can debate and argue and dislike certain policies of the Israeli government (as much as some despise the US governments actions in very distant lands – or perhaps the Iranian, Saudian or Syrian governments? Those who actually sided with, and lauded Saddam Hussein in the Gulf War – and later cheered Bin Laden?) – but that doesn’t mean one has to continually bring up the legitimacy of the nation. Why is the UN vote on Israel in 1947 any less legitimate than any other country’s existence? Israel was immediately attacked, on all sides, by all Arab countries after that vote – and won. Attacked again in 67 and again 73. And won. The result is hanging on to strategic territory – most of it mountanous. Right? Probably not? Smart? Probably not. But the arabs (look at free Gaza) have shown what they do as soon as they are given land back – rocket attacks from behind civillians.
It’s very complicated – I know – I live it. I would give all the land back in a minute for a real peace. I would have Jerusalem as the international capital of the world’s faiths – who would care if there was peace anyway – like Europe – I would open borders.
But until that day – Israel, mistakes and all, is still a nation. Granted after WW2 to the remaining Jews of the world. It’s smaller than New Jersey, surrounded by not one single democracy and all weapons, chemical biological and now maybe nuclear – aimed at it.
Where should the 6 million Israelis go? And why?
They’ve made the desert bloom, become the world’s most stable economy even in this recession, and have given the world more per capita PhD’s, Medical and Technological advancements than any other nation.
It began with a hope and a dream, was given legitimacy in 1947 – and has made mistakes since – but is still only 62 years young.
How quick we are to judge a country and ride the peticoats of a senile old reporter who since, and you can check her website, has profoundly apologized.
All you anti-semites can now crawl back into yur holes and wait for the next incident to rear your ugly heads.
The rest of you are welcome to visit Israel – it’s the nicest time of the year. Elton will be performing June 30, followed by Rod Stewart July 1. (Elvis Costello – kiss my butt.)