@Jeruba
“Well I have had lunch, but I guess there’s room for dessert.”
“Well, I had lunch, but I guess there’s room for dessert.”
The first is just wordy and the second doesn’t change the meaning at all. No one imagines that you are referring to some distant point at which you had lunch and are pining for the day when you can have lunch again. Unless of course you added, “Well I had lunch, but alas it is a fleeting memory and yea there may be room in my belly for some dessert being that I have not eaten lunch since that fateful day.”
The past perfect “had had” places it earlier in time than the action of “chose,” which is in the simple past.
But of course it happened before you chose. That’s implicit. What could you choose from unless there were choices presented? I still think it sounds like a stutter.
Best example I found was this blog-usingenglish.com wherein
anonymous states:
”The verb “have” acts as an auxiliary verb for the perfect aspects/tenses.
The perfect aspects are formed using “have + past participle”.
Now, keep in mind that “have” is a verb unto itself. When “have” functions as its own auxiliary in the past perfect, we can choose to leave out “have” as auxiliary so as to avoid the confusion that you are making reference to now. In this manner it is not the past perfect, but the simple past. Take a look at these examples:
Up until lunchtime, he had not eaten anything.
had – as auxiliary + not eaten – eaten as past participle – had not eaten
Up until lunchtime, he had had nothing to eat. (best example I can think of now)
had – auxiliary verb in the past to form the past perfect – + had – past participle – to form the past perfect -
The past form of “have” which is “had” is functioning as an auxiliary in order to form the past perfect with the past participle of “have” which is “had”.
had/auxiliary + had/past participle = had had – past perfect aspect of the verb “to have”
We can leave out the first “had” and put the sentence in the simple past. The meaning is not changed in this manner.
Up until lunch time, he had nothing to eat. or He had nothing to eat up until lunchtime._”