@johnnydohey
What can I say. I think the stigma against psychiatry comes with the stigma against the mentally ill. There is no conspiracy. There is a lot that we know, and a lot that we don’t know. The link you provided above is one of many, many antipsychiatry movies.
In the end, studying the brain, especially higher order functions of the brain like behaviors, emotions, thoughts, fantasies, jealousies, love, hate, suicidality, homicidality, loneliness, meaning, loss, angst, etc is a lot harder than studying the bladder or the kidney or the liver. The result is that we know a lot less about the mind than the rest of the body or lower-level functions of the brain like movement, sensation, reflexes, balance, sight, etc. This is a big problem because psychiatry does not fit easily within society’s expectation of medicine. There is no test that gives you an answer, no drug that gives you a cure. Patients tell us constellations of symptoms and we match those to studies where we’ve examined hundreds or thousands of similar people with similar symptoms.
Unfortunately, psychiatric illness are syndromes and not categorized by etiology. The reason for this is that we don’t really understand the etiology for a lot of the illnesses. We likely understand depression the best. We can say you have Major Depressive Disoder based on your symptoms, but a diagnosis of MDD doesn’t tell other docs if it’s caused by a serotonin deficiency, by a narcissistic injury, by being rejected by your true love, by learning that your parents are fallible, or by coming to terms with your mortality. Depending on the underlying cause, a different course of treatment is recommended. This is why the lay public gets so confused. Lots of people get diagnosed with MDD but everyone gets a different treatment recommendation.
The creeping commercialism in medicine is another huge problem. Big pharma and the insurance industry have majorly polluted psychiatry. That said, most psych meds are prescribed by GPs. I agree that there is overdiagnosis of bipolar or adhd, but it does not mean that there aren’t people who truly have bipolar or adhd. It’s very important to find professionals who you trust. Personally, I never take contributions or materials from any for-profit company. My prescribing habits are based exclusively on my reading the literature and my clinical/anecdotal experience.
In the end, as a psychiatrist, I know I prevented hundreds more suicides than I missed. I’ve treated dozens of homicidal patients, but none of them have actually killed someone. I’ve helped people cope, find meaning in their travails, deepen relationships, put horrifying experiences in iraq and afghanistan behind them, and I’ve prescribed a lot of meds with the purposed to lighten people’s symptom burden. People come to me when they are suffering and I do my best to help them feel better. I try to use the least invasive methods first and progress to one or more meds if needed. The notion that there is a psychiatric agenda to pathologize the population is very strange to me. My only agenda is developed in conjunction with my patients.
Returning to your situation, of course, you are free to seek help from a psychiatrist or not. From my reading the thread of this conversation it seems you are having symptoms that are distressing to you. As a psychiatrist, I think there are tools we have available to us that may help you. Or perhaps, as is always possible, our tools will not work. The only way for you to know is to seek out a psychiatrist and try it out. My comments above are driven exclusively by my wish to offer advice that will help.