Ever the flame bait. No one can resist. I do think there are people for whom English is a second language. In fact, quite a few of them. However, it is easy for me to tell who they are, and I give them a pass. Other people seem to be unable to distinguish between non-natives and the uneducated.
I disagree with @Seek_Kolinahr that people deliberately use txtspk to piss off others. I think that for the most part, people use txtspk because they find it useful. I think it is useful for them partly because they are typing on little keypads on phones. It’s just more efficient to type fewer letters.
There was a time when I invented a lot of contractions for many, many words. Wordperfect would correct the “misspellings” for me. Word will do that, too. Too bad Chrome doesn’t have such a feature. It does have the next best thing—a spell checker. As does Firefox, and, for all I know, maybe even IE by now.
I think the fact that people ignore the misspellings (and the spell checkers should prompt with better spellings) is probably more a matter of laziness and efficiency (both good things, in my book).
I’ve done a lot of chatting in my day. I can type six or seven sentences in the time it took some of my correspondents to type one. I say the hell with spelling mistakes in chat. It just slows things down too much, especially when you are chatting with someone who couldn’t finish a novel in a life time at the speed they type. If you are one of those people and you are chatting with me—feel free to use every short cut you know. I don’t want to grow old waiting for a response.
But no further apologies for bad grammar or txtspk from me. It does annoy me when people do the simple things like their instead of they’re; loose or choose instead of lose or chose; and the like. It breaks the flow of understanding as I wonder what they mean to say for a second. It makes me less likely to want to read further, because they make me do too much sleuthing in order to try to figure out what they mean.
But here’s (non hears) my main answer to the question, carefully tucked away at the bottom where no one with the attention span of a mosquito will ever see it. I think there is a correlation between the amount of attention paid to spelling and grammar and the complexity of the thoughts being conveyed.
The people who use txtspk tend to be younger and less educated. The older people who don’t use good grammar are probably also not as well educated.
When fluther makes a big stink about these things, what they are trying to convey is that this is a site (my fingers typed “sight” before I fixed it) for intelligent people; where you can get well thought-out answers to questions; where you can socialize with other people who can think interesting thoughts.
It chases away the uneducated and the boring (@ChazMaz notwithstanding) (it’s a joke; it’s a joke—I highly respect his contributions, even if he is, occasionally, wrong ;-). Thus the intelligent are left behind, as they are the only ones with any consistent ability to spell properly (or pay attention to spell checkers) and to use grammar correctly.
Now, let me be clear—you don’t need a degree to be considered educated. There are plenty of people here with nothing more than a high school education who are very interesting and express themselves very well. And similarly, a degree does not mean you can think and be interesting.
That’s why I chose to say “complex thinking” rather than educated. There may be a high correlation between education and complex thinking, but there are plenty of people who are officially uneducated but are functionally highly educated.
Sure, I can easily understand poorly written answers. But it is not nearly as easy as it is to understand well written answers. There’s just one thing I don’t get: why is it that people seem to go around and around on this so many times. Isn’t it perfectly obvious what is going on? You might criticize and yell at people to improve their grammar, but will that really help them do so? I doubt it. What they need is a writing class and I don’t see how fluther can be that for anyone.