Hey there MoxieGal. I actually met my wonderful girlfriend on Okcupid.
Though I am pretty atypical compared to most guys (I don’t show off my chest and I don’t send messages out that say ‘sup babe u wan hook up i can be ur sugar daddy hot mami”)
I do think my advice can still be helpful.
What I did, is answer as many of the questions as I could (I think I finally got to about 1400 questions). This increases your match percentages with potential matches.
After that, I used the search feature to search girls in my area and I ranked them by highest match percentage to lowest percent. I am not one to think with my dick, so I would pick girls that I thought were both physically attractive and mentally interesting and then message them based on something from their profile that I thought was interesting.
I initially got quite a few replies and got a few numbers before finally meeting my lady in person and instantly hitting it off (we were matched 88%)
Say a cute girl said she was interested in violin and hiking on her profile… I’d send her a message like this:
Hey there (name), it’s a lovely foggy sunday here and I’m just sitting here wondering what style of violin you play? Go on any interesting hikes lately?
Something like that.
About pictures, emphasize your good features. Use good lighting (early morning and late afternoon light makes you look alluring and mysterious) and be honest about your qualities. If you are overweight, don’t hide it. Also, remember to smile. “Action” shots and pictures showing your talents. My girlfriend’s profile had a picture of her standing on a big round boulder in Norway and I knew it would be lurve at first message.
For me, though, the biggest attraction factors were always:
Cute, not trashy, pictures.
Uniqueness of interests and quirkiness.
Intellect.